Nicola Sturgeon Loses Another Round to JK Rowling

Former Scottish First Minister Nicola Sturgeon is the kind of politician who gives politicians a bad name. She's the kind of character who seems to have no capacity for shame whatsoever. Every pronouncement she makes, even if it completely contradicts what she said yesterday, is delivered with absolute conviction. My favorite example of this, and it's relevant to this story, happened back in January 2023 when Sturgeon found herself on the ropes over her support for trans people. 

Sturgeon was a big fan of self-ID, the ability of people to simply announce they were male or female and then get a certificate from the government saying it was so. She championed a Gender Recognition Reform Bill that would have made this the law in Scotland. But about a month later her bill came into conflict with reality in the form of Isla Bryson, a trans woman who also happened to be a convicted rapist. The question at the time was whether or not Scottish authorities would be forced to send Bryson to a women's prison. That led to this embarrassing reversal from Sturgeon where she said that, of course, a male rapist wouldn't be sent to a women's prison.

🎥 Nicola Sturgeon forced into humiliating u-turn as Isla Bryson to be moved to men's prison: https://t.co/iEt1lntFtK pic.twitter.com/4VCHv0K0oB

— Scottish Express (@ScotExpress) January 26, 2023

And a few days after that, Sturgeon was pressed to explain the contradiction and utterly failed to do so in one of the worst woke-word-salad moments you'll ever see. (The tweet says 2025 but this interview aired on Jan. 30, 2023).

Nicola Sturgeon says she should have paused legislation on changing gender.

At the time, prominent voices asked for a pause. The one who refused consistently was Nicola Sturgeon. She was resolute: “trans women are women.”

Then, Isla Bryson came along.

pic.twitter.com/bw0J8CcodK

— Peter A Smith (@PeterAdamSmith) August 11, 2025

It's almost as if her worldview doesn't make any sense. Two weeks later, Sturgeon announced she was resigning. Six weeks after that (late March 2023) she was gone. But two years later, she still couldn't manage to answer a question about this. Watch as she talks herself into another corner.

Nicola Sturgeon tells ITV people who 'commit the most heinous crimes against women forfeit the right to be the gender of their choice'. The first minister was answering a question on convicted rapist Isla Bryson, who is transgender.

You can watch Nicola Sturgeon: The Interview… pic.twitter.com/aY23KcgPpp

— ITV News (@itvnews) August 11, 2025

For obvious reasons, Sturgeon was frequently at odds with J.K. Rowling both during and after her time in office. 

"Sturgeon is making a big mistake in thinking that by denying science and trashing women’s rights she looks progressive, because the public are smarter than that... women won’t forget what she’s done, and they won’t forgive." https://t.co/2B6fE3CMse

— J.K. Rowling (@jk_rowling) January 21, 2023

However, trans woman and paedophile Katie Dolatowski, who covertly filmed a 12-year-old and attempted to rape a 10-year-old, both offences committed in women’s public bathrooms, IS a woman and remains in the women’s prison from which Adam Graham is to be removed. 2/4 pic.twitter.com/m9atvo9dg7

— J.K. Rowling (@jk_rowling) January 27, 2023

Rowling is clearly not a fan.

'We've lost all sense of rationality in [the gender] debate,' said Nicola Sturgeon.

Only one side has lost rationality.
Only one side pretends there's more than two sexes.
Only one side lets male rapists into women's prisons.
Only one side supports child sterilisation.

Yours. https://t.co/HavwzXYXST

— J.K. Rowling (@jk_rowling) August 11, 2025

I see Nicola Sturgeon is once again complaining that I posted a picture of myself wearing a T-shirt with her name on it and the legend 'Destroyer of Women's Rights.' Apparently this didn't 'elevate the debate.'

Is there a clinical term for an individual who has extreme thinness… pic.twitter.com/O4MDKQBnrS

— J.K. Rowling (@jk_rowling) August 22, 2025

There are many more examples over the past several years, including Rowling's review of Sturgeon's autobiography. But recently, Sturgeon has been in the news for a new reason. Her husband of 15 years was just convicted of embezzlement of several hundred thousand pounds.

Former SNP chief executive Peter Murrell has been sentenced to five years and three months in jail after he admitted to embezzling more than £400,000 from the party.

Murrell - the estranged husband of Nicola Sturgeon - used the funds to buy goods ranging from cars and a motorhome to kitchenware and toiletries.

The 61-year-old's sentence was backdated to 25 May, when he was remanded in custody after pleading guilty.

So, just to be really clear, he stole this money from the party that his wife was once the leader of while they were still married. In fact, although Nicola has announced her intent to divorce him, they are still married now. This has led many people to wonder how Nicola never noticed all the fancy things he was bringing home.

'Nicola Sturgeon knew full well what her husband was doing and how those luxury purchases were funded'

Nicola Sturgeon tried to have Alex Salmond jailed to stop him exposing Peter Murrell's crimes, senior Tory MP David Davis has claimed 👇 pic.twitter.com/SmVU5U7oRH

— The Herald (@heraldscotland) July 16, 2026

Sturgeon has maintained that, like Col. Klink in the old TV show, she knew nothing. Memes of Sturgeon as a blind woman circulated.

Nicola Sturgeon leaving her house whilst her husband is in Edinburgh High Court for embezzling £460000 today. She apparently knew nothing! pic.twitter.com/Ifn65gWwVX

— Robbie🐾🐾 (@RobMclovin1) May 25, 2026

Rowling also got in on it.

All these cynics saying Sturgeon must have noticed top-of-the range coffee makers and designer handbags appearing out of thin air in her home: there are a hundred innocent explanations. She probably assumed the elves were pleased with her or something. pic.twitter.com/jiYLBWZ4yx

— J.K. Rowling (@jk_rowling) May 29, 2026

A couple days ago, Rowling added this:

I’m astonished that Sturgeon turns out to be not only a world-class misogynist, the blindest wife ever to enjoy the fruits of a fraudster husband’s theft, but also profoundly disloyal to the party and the political allies who once revered her. 🧵 https://t.co/GsnBL1kSLy

— J.K. Rowling (@jk_rowling) August 7, 2026

Sturgeon, for her part, is now living in London and makes the rounds to various public events including one that happened this week where she claimed misogyny was behind claims that she must have known about her husband's crimes.

Sturgeon has repeatedly denied any knowledge of Murrell’s crimes, saying she was lied to and betrayed, a position she reiterated on Saturday while speaking to Iain Dale for an All Talk show at the Edinburgh Fringe.

The former SNP leader further told the festival crowd that she had “learned a lot about what he did at the same time all of you did, because over three years he never really levelled with me”...

“I'm not trying to escape legitimate scrutiny and accountability. I just think that there has been – there is – an element, quite a big element, of sexism and misogyny over how I've been treated in relation to the crimes of a man, that wouldn't have been the case had I been the man.”

She also attacked Rowling as someone obsessed with her.

The comments came after Dale asked an audience-submitted question about whether there should be an “amnesty with JK Rowling”. The Harry Potter author had made headlines the previous day with an attack on Sturgeon, alleging that she had been “the blindest wife ever to enjoy the fruits of a fraudster husband’s theft”.

Sturgeon said: “I'll say this as gently and as directly, I'm not at war with JK Rowling. She seems to be at war with me, so if there's going to be an amnesty, I think it's probably going to have to come from her.”

She went on: “We disagree on more than one thing. We disagreed on independence, we clearly disagree on trans rights – but my God, that woman is obsessed with me.

“I don't spend as much time thinking about her as she clearly does, so sorry.”

So there you have it. All of Sturgeon's critics are obsessed and/or misogynists. And she did absolutely nothing wrong and knew absolutely nothing about her husband's crimes.

I guess Sturgeon still has her fans though, I can't imagine why. Some of them will buy this and so long as they do she'll keep selling it.

Editor's Note: Do you enjoy HotAir's conservative reporting that takes on the radical Left and woke media? Support our work so that we can continue to bring you the truth.

Join HotAir VIP and use promo code FIGHT to receive 60% off your membership.