"Communists want people to be stupid, flabby and angry".
It's not a quote from some serious public intellectual. Heck — it's just me, Mitch, a beleaguered conservative writer in a blue state whose soon-to-be-ex governor thinks all conservatives are "Nazis".
But this "story" brings to mind a quote from a much more serious thinker, GK Chesterton: "It is impossible to caricature that which caricatures itself."
Today's self-caricature: Big Left's emerging view that physical fitness is "fascist" (emphasis added by me)(
Right-wing ideology has crept into gyms across the country. Is this a new phenomenon, or is the very idea of "fitness" ripe for politicization? Is our idea of fitness inherently fascist? We find out with political commentator Hasan Piker, historian Natalia Mehlman Petrzela and professor Ava Purkiss, author of Fit Citizens.
You might look at presence of Hasan Piker - silver-spoon mama's boy who does his foul-mouthed podcast from what may as well be his parents' basement — as an expert on either fitness or "fascism" as proof that Chesterton was a pollyanna. And you'd be right.
Because some of the "experts" on this topic are enough to make you wonder if you've wandered into a Babylon Bee article:
🚨 “The More Dysgenic, the Better”: Beatrice Adler-Bolton Says the Left Must Give Up the “Fantasy of Being Fitter Than the Fascists” At Socialism 2026, Adler-Bolton argues that “fitness is a measure of relative disposability under capitalism” and says the goal should not be to become “more useful to the ruling order.” She says the left should not try to beat fascists “at their own game” by becoming “fitter, more eugenic.” “In fact, the more dysgenic, the better, I think.” She closes by arguing that revolution is not “a contest between optimized and properly prepared bodies” and that the very idea is itself fascist.
— Stu Smith (@thestustustudio) September 5, 2026
The Nazis preached fitness. Nazis were fascists. Therefore, fitness is "fascist".
No, seriously:
Fitness culture and fatphobia are fascistic fads, although their fans feign them as the favoured formulae for fleeing our mind worlds towards a flab-free one. Fitness influencers are basically peddling Nazism.
Imagining fascists, people likely think of goose-stepping Germans. Nazis are scary, but the SS’s marching chokehold on the public’s imagination when we broach the subject of fascism leaves the vast majority of us ill-equipped to identify fascistic tendencies elsewhere.
Nazis propagandized fitness as Germans’ duty to the nation. This was highly compatible with other parts of the Nazi project, namely to manufacture a homogenous Aryan population and erase all bodies that did not match their ideal. These are heinous strains of logic which have been exported from fascist movements and sewn into the fabric of public life.
The fascistic part of fitness culture is the way it frames exercise as a moral lifestyle that we should all — every single one of us — aspire to. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention suggests that the reasons why you want to lose weight might include wanting to “see your kids get married” and this can be attained by organizing one’s entire lifestyle around weight loss.
A real professor even says so:
I can’t believe this is real NPR is now saying that fitness is “Right wing” and fitness is also “a tool of fascism” “We have to think about how fitness can be a shorthand or a subtext to dehumanize people, debase people, divide them — when we can use fitness as a proxy to do that sort of separation, It can be a tool of soft fascism, maybe even actual fascism.” Democrats CANNOT win the next election. We cannot go back and descend into this woke nonsense She literally talks about how all the ways fitness “radicalizes” Liberals have lost their minds
— Wall Street Apes (@WallStreetApes) November 14, 2026
I'm going to guess Professor Purkis's "research" was funded by a Biden-era federal grant.