It's the Attacks on Speech in the Anglosphere That Really Get Me...

Nov 18, 2026 4:40 PM
Premium
Advertisement
It's the Attacks on Speech in the Anglosphere That Really Get Me...
AP Photo/Andrew Harnik
VIP

I've written a lot about my disgust with the attitude of the Europoors toward speech, and the EU speech regulations are a genuine problem for Americans because the regulators have a financial cudgel to beat the social media and news corporations into submission. 

But for all the legal dangers the European Union and national governments pose to free speech in the United States and the entire "free world," my gut reaction to the decline in free speech rights in the Anglosphere is much more emotionally wrenching. 

What the EU, the French, and the Germans are doing is a policy problem we will face, and we may not be able to resolve it adequately. But the decline of free speech in the Anglosphere is a cultural problem that strikes at the heart of who we are as a political bloc. 

The problem is not exactly new. Canada has had aggressive speech police for quite a while now, and writers and speakers have had to defend themselves time and again as government bodies harass them in the name of protecting "human rights." And then there are professional organizations that can take away licenses or force people to get reeducated. Ask Jordan Peterson about that. Or others...

A ruling by the British Columbia Human Rights Tribunal which imposed a penalty of $750,000 on a trans heretic is as chilling in its implication as it is draconian in its punishment.

The extraordinary judgement creates a hierarchy of beliefs in that if a person says they are transgender then everyone is obliged to believe them, regardless of any skepticism. To do otherwise is to deny their existence, says the tribunal.

The ruling has all the hallmarks of the Spanish Inquisition: a government-sanctioned body seeking to compel people to conform to a certain orthodoxy on pain of punishment. The tribunal isn’t yet using the Iron Maiden but by imposing such a large cash award the financial pain is considerable and punitive.

The man at the centre of the case, Barry Neufeld, was ordered to pay compensation of $750,000 to be distributed among the LGBTQ members of the Chilliwack Teachers’ Association, the group that complained about him.

The tribunal claims that it is balancing the rights of free expression against the evils of hate and discrimination. The judgement, however, is heavily weighted in finding Neufeld guilty, but when it comes to freedom of speech the “fix” is in early.

The ruling says that merely denying the existence of trans people is not, on its own, hate speech. But it says, “speech which denies the authentic existence of trans and gender diverse people bears a hallmark of hate against them.”

Countless cases show people being harassed and punished across Anglosphere countries, though thankfully we here in the United States can still appeal to our First Amendment rights — even as our speech is regulated by proxy, with governments around the world fencing off what can be said on social media. 

Arrests for saying the wrong thing are separated by minutes, not days or weeks, in the United Kingdom these days. 

Australia is arguably the worst offender among the Anglosphere countries. They have invented a concept called the "Digital Duty of Care" that requires social media companies to conjure up reasons for denying people the right to express opinions, and it's not even clear what does or does not cross the line. 

Who could have guessed that "tradwife" content would fit, but now it does. It's up to the imaginations of the regulators and politicians, and the smart move for social media companies is to just suppress whatever might offend the woke. 

It's not just my prejudicial loyalty to the Anglosphere and my natural preference for those who speak the greatest language to have ever existed; I fear for free speech everywhere partly because the English pioneered freedom of speech in the modern world, and when the Anglosphere countries abandon the idea, who left will defend it in the West? 

Nobody expects the French to do so, and the Germans are very touchy about it because their history makes them especially so (although, ironically, the Nazis were not free speech absolutists, to say the least, so linking freedom of speech to them is a bit odd). 

No, it's the Anglosphere that bears the "white man's burden" in this regard. (Yes, I chose that phrase more to offend in the name of free speech than to express approval of it). 

It's our job to stand up for unpopular speech and keep the flame of freedom alive, and we are doing a piss poor job of it. 

Editor’s Note: Here at HotAir, we’ve been dealing with real government suppression of free speech for YEARS. Despite the threats and consequences, we refuse to go silent and remain committed to delivering the truth.

Help us fight back against government censorship by joining HotAir VIP and using promo code FIGHT to receive 60% off your membership.

Comments

Recommended

Trending on HotAir Videos