“It’s funny because this is a guy who spends all day, every day, meticulously designing flowers out of icing. His whole life is gay, okay?” Kimmel said. “I don’t know if the wrong cake might bring that to life or what.”

He then mocked Jack Phillips, who he sarcastically referred to as “the totally straight cake baker,” over his appearance.

“You would think that someone who looks like the Reba McEntire version of Colonel Sanders would be more sympathetic to gender identity issues,” Kimmel laughed.