The Tamed Liberal West Doesn’t Understand the Threat of Islam

Advertisement
Excerpt Chronicles Magazine chroniclesmagazine.org

A quarter century ago, as the “War on Terror” was beginning, neoconservatives and liberals entertained the idea that America might do more than just punish the Islamists responsible for 9/11. By the time George W. Bush launched the invasion of Iraq in 2003, America’s bipartisan elite had convinced itself that deposing Saddam Hussein would bring about more than just regime change in Iraq; it would bring liberal democracy to the entire Middle East. 

But 25 years after the 9/11 attacks, the West is not exporting democracy; it’s importing Islam. Supposedly universal Western values have not only failed to take root in the Islamic world, but they are also retreating in Europe and the United States, as liberals themselves never tire of telling us. By contrast, Islam is the fastest-growing religion in the world, including in Europe and North America. Meanwhile, American Christians who once looked to sub-Saharan Africa as the demographic future of the faith must now confront the fact that Islam is outpacing Christianity there, too, and its expansion owes much to the use of violence, which was also indispensable to the establishment of Islam in North Africa—formerly a Roman and Christian land—some 1,300 years ago.

The clash of civilizations is a clash of faiths, but well-educated modern Westerners have adopted a moral anthropology that deludes them about the nature of the conflict. For good Europeans and Americans, religion is voluntary and indifferent to the law. The law, and the state, is concerned with individuals and their rights. Liberal Westerners do not consider this a mere Western belief, however, but the natural order and aspiration of all humanity. Thus, for the college-educated Westerner, the contest is not between Islam and some rival religion; it’s rather a struggle between freedom and tyranny, and because tyranny is unnatural, once a tyrant like Saddam Hussein is removed—or a tyrannical regime like Iran’s—the result will be a liberal democracy wherein Islam will have the same status as Christianity has in the West today.

This is a charmingly Eurocentric conceit. In fact, the Western way of life is neither humanity’s default condition nor its inexorable destiny. The West once took religion as seriously as the Islamic world still does. What changed the West were a series of catastrophic wars among Christians in the 16th and 17th centuries, along with the development of new political philosophies that grounded society and government in principles other than those of religion. Thomas Hobbes’ Leviathan, first published in 1651, was pivotal. Hobbes saw a war of all against all, driven by man’s natural vainglory—including pride in his religious opinions—as the original condition of the species. To preserve life, Hobbes argued that everyone, and everyone’s religious opinions, must submit to a supreme earthly territorial authority: what we now call the state.

Continue Reading at Chronicles Magazine

Comments

VIP

Join the Conversation

VIP members get the ability to comment on articles.

Recommended

Trending on HotAir Videos