Could Sore Loser Laws Keep Haley Off No Labels Ticket?

At first glance, it appears that state election laws in several key states would bar Haley from appearing on the ballot as a third-party presidential candidate, once she has lost the GOP primary. Michigan, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Texas, Arkansas, and Alabama bar a candidate who has lost a presidential primary in one party from running for office as the nominee of another party. ...

Advertisement

But there will be debates about whether those state laws apply to presidential candidates, or just candidates for state office. There are those who argue that sore loser laws cannot apply to presidential elections, because the voter is not actually voting for the presidential candidate, but for the elector to the electoral college. This dispute would have to be sorted out by the Supreme Court, on a tight deadline before people start casting ballots for the 2024 election. In Minnesota and Virginia, early voting for the general election starts September 20.

Add up the electoral votes of the eight states listed above, and you’re at 131 electoral votes that would be out of reach for No Labels, including Haley’s home state, unless the Supreme Court struck down those sore loser laws.

Ed Morrissey

I doubt that it will become an issue in the first place, but it's a good question. Haley's not likely to end up on a No Labels ticket in the first place, not without destroying her political career afterward. Liz Cheney's more likely than Haley. 

FWIW, I think those sore-loser laws stand up to constitutional scrutiny for state offices, but I think the Supreme Court would see it as an illegitimate prerequisite for offices controlled by the US Constitution. 

Join the conversation as a VIP Member

Trending on HotAir Videos

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement