Why the Border Bill Died

Nourished in the seclusion of backroom negotiations, the long-rumored bipartisan Senate border bill soon wilted in the blazing sun of public attention. The border proposal had been intended to convince Republicans to vote for a bigger package that included military aid for Ukraine and Israel. Yet the measure was proclaimed dead within days of being unveiled by lead negotiators Chris Murphy (D-CT), James Lankford (R-OK), and Kyrsten Sinema (I-AZ).

Advertisement

     The border bill has provoked considerable controversy. Its proponents say that it is a major step toward border control that delivers on the long-term goals of many conservatives. Some in the press claim that Republican opposition to the bill is a sign that the party is not serious about governing at all. The bill’s critics, however, have argued that the mechanics of the bill actually undermine the stated goal of restoring an orderly asylum process.

     Even if the border bill is dead, there are still some lessons to be learned from an autopsy. 

Ed Morrissey

This itself is a detailed autopsy from the ever-reliable Fred Bauer, so read it all. My general sense is that it failed because it didn't do anything to address the real emergency at the border, and would have instead enshrined this level of illegal crossings as the norm. It was a bad joke, the kind of proposal you'd expect from people devoted to the status quo rather than real change. 

Join the conversation as a VIP Member

Trending on HotAir Videos

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement