Clearly, symbols can have different meanings for different people. I disagree with Professor Bruski, but respect his right to raise such objections. The question is whether others respect the right of those with opposing views, including viewing this flag as an important and inspiring symbol of the American Revolution.

The censorship of the image strikes me as a clear denial of free speech rights for this student. I obviously do not agree with the historical interpretation [of the Confederate flag in another case — Ed], but I am far more concerned about the constitutional interpretation of the school district allowing such censorship of images.

It is an ironic moment for a flag that symbolized the resistance to overbearing government actions and the denial of core rights in the American Revolution.

[The school in question has now retreated and will allow the student to keep his Gadsden Flag image on his backpack. Colorado governor Jared Polis’ strong scolding of the school was not only surprising, as Polis is a Democrat, but apparently was also effective. Turley’s right that it was ironic, but it was also a clarifying moment as well. — Ed]