The Olivia Dunne Experience rolled into Rupp Arena in downtown Lexington, Kentucky Friday night, and outside of a few fans holding signs, including one student asking “Livvy, will you marry me?”, it didn’t exactly feel like the highest-paid female college athlete and social media superstar was in the building.

It was a completely different scene inside Rupp compared to a week ago in Salt Lake City where the 20-year-old Dunne received treatment typically reserved for the likes of Harry Styles, the Jonas Brothers, or Justin Bieber. Things were so crazy in Utah that Dunne had to tell fans it was time to chill out a little bit and get back to being gymnastics fans — or at least tone down the bro-ness a little bit.