One year after Middlebury College students shut down a planned debate between the American Enterprise Institute’s Charles Murray and Professor Allison Stanger—injuring Stanger in the process—the student newspaper decided to print a retrospective photo of Murray taken at the aborted event.

This decision was apparently controversial: an apologetic note from The Middlebury Campus’s editor-in-chief revealed that “most of the section editors, and the managing editor” thought it would be inappropriate to print a photo of Murray. A photo.

According to Ethan Brady, the editor-in-chief: