“Did you ever ask yourself what would Jesus do in this particular situation?” Paula Faris asked Phillips. “Instead of denying them, do you think maybe Jesus would have said I don’t accept this but I’m going to love you anyways?”

When the baker responded that he did not think Jesus would have made the cake because it contradicted his teaching, Behar cut in: “You don’t? O c’mon. Jesus would have made the cake.”

As Phillips tried to explain himself, Behar continued to insist loudly: “Jesus, that’s a deal breaker. Jesus is going to make the cake.”