Why "fat-shaming" celebrity feminists is counterproductive

While most conservatives pointed out how insensitive Dunham’s comment was, some preferred to say it was because no one would have sex with her because she’s unattractive and fat. You can find these views on several websites, YouTube videos, and comment sections. Since many of them are friends and good people, I’d rather talk about why I don’t think this tactic works instead of call them out.

Schumer and Dunham are probably in the 8 to 12 size range. First Lady Michelle Obama, also a frequent target of nicknames like “Moochelle,” is in the 8 to 10 size range. These women aren’t even what clothing manufacturers consider “plus size.” Many women, myself included, are their size or larger. Many of Dunham and Schumer’s most ardent criticizers probably know and love women who are physically larger. These women aren’t necessarily following the politics of why Dunham and Schumer are in the news, but they hear comments about their weight. Rather than conservatives leading with criticism of Dunham and Schumer’s weight or looks, our message would be better received if we led with substance, not snark.