“If there was an Osama bin Laden at that location … at that time … if he was present over there, there is a proper way to go about it,” Agha says.

When asked if her choice of words means she isn’t sure the al-Qaida chief was where the U.S. said he was, she replies: “Of course not. If he was there, you guys would’ve been there a lot sooner.”

To be clear, Agha is no Islamist — nor is she anti-American. In fact, she hopes to study in the U.S. someday.