Phillies shortstop: We'll win in five

“He’s been Nostradamus, that’s what I heard,” Yankees catcher Jorge Posada said. “He’s been (making) a lot of good predictions, so we’ve got to take that away from him.”

Earlier this season, Rollins forecast the Yankees and Phillies would meet in the Fall Classic this year.

“He predicted we’d play them in the World Series about seven years ago, too,” Yankees shortstop Derek Jeter said. “You make enough predictions, I guess you’d be right most of the time, right?”