An early example in the Biden administration of online Dems getting rough with one reporter who was “unhelpful” to their side pour encourager les autres.
If you read last night’s post about Tanden’s nomination, you already have some idea of what this is about. She’s in trouble partly because of her Twitter habit, and not just her critical commentary of lefty heroes like Bernie Sanders. She’s also jabbed at centrist Republicans like Susan Collins — and Lisa Murkowski, who looks to be Tanden’s last chance to provide the 50th vote she’d need for confirmation. Tanden has deleted many, many tweets since being nominated (as well as apologized privately for some of the things she’s said) to try to clean up the mess she made online.
But this tweet, curiously, remains available to the public as I write this:
No offense but this sounds like you’re high on your own supply.
You know, we know, and everyone knows this is all garbage. Just stop. https://t.co/0MzDYCpDyc
— Neera Tanden (@neeratanden) December 1, 2017
WaPo reporter Seung Min Kim went looking through Tanden’s Twitter archive for any tweets she may have sent in the past about Murkowski, recognizing that those could matter at a moment when Tanden’s chances hinge on Murky’s support. She found the one above. And then, as reporters routinely did during the Trump years with presidential tweets, she showed it to the target to get her reaction. The moment was caught on film and circulated widely last night:
.@seungminkim showing Murkowski an old Tanden tweet targeting her
“High on my own supply? That’s interesting” pic.twitter.com/gdhaYpQuvf
— Igor Bobic (@igorbobic) February 24, 2021
That’s all she did. She took a publicly available comment made by a candidate for a cabinet position and asked an elected official what she thought. And some of Tanden’s Twitter fanboys went ballistic, accusing Kim of trying to tank her nomination by showing Murkowski something at a delicate moment that might influence her vote, never mind that she was likely to see it eventually anyway.
A few weren’t polite about it either:
Let’s check in on my email inbox pic.twitter.com/OjhT5uOvt2
— Seung Min Kim (@seungminkim) February 25, 2021
Meanwhile …. pic.twitter.com/JSfaVQydqu
— Seung Min Kim (@seungminkim) February 25, 2021
Kim’s employer, the Washington Post, issued this statement this afternoon condemning the “racist, sexist, and ill-informed attacks” aimed at Kim today:
Latest statement from Washington Post National Editor @stevenjay on the harassment of reporter Seung Min Kim pic.twitter.com/2mXpshvYlZ
— Kristine Coratti Kelly (@kriscoratti) February 25, 2021
I’m curious about this new standard among Tanden-ites in which asking a senator for comment on public material is some sort of offense against decency. How long was Kim supposed to avoid asking Murkowski a pertinent question about the nominee’s view of her, knowing that another reporter was likely to find the same old Tanden tweet and get the scoop by asking Murkowski instead?
The answer is obvious. She was supposed to wait until Murkowski had already cast her vote to confirm and couldn’t change her mind. Journalism is virtuous to the extent it serves the party, as it did during the Trump years. Once its interests and the party’s diverge, the party’s interests take precedence.
Whether out of basic decency or because she knows how bad it looks for her acolytes to be harassing a reporter, Tanden herself amplified WaPo’s defense of Kim:
Notably, @neeratanden has retweeted the statement in support of @seungminkim asking Sen. Murkowski a question about an old Neera tweet. pic.twitter.com/b3RyP8ljx0
— Jennifer Epstein (@jeneps) February 25, 2021
Eh, probably too late. Murkowski looks to be leaning no and Kyrsten Sinema has been conspicuously quiet. I think Erick Erickson’s right that this ugly episode might finish her off, as it illustrates one of the reasons her slashing tweets are a liability: “This is exactly why Tanden cannot be confirmed. She fostered some of the original online mobs long before Trump was even a thing.” If the centrist Republicans in the Senate are looking to move on from Trump, and Murkowski certainly is, the online conduct of Tanden and her angriest supporters are an easy way for them to draw a line in the sand. “We need more civility from our public servants, starting with their online presence.” In fact, watch McConnell make a variation of that point below. If Tanden tanks because of her tweets and what happened to Kim today, that’s a strong incentive for every climber in Washington to keep their nose clean on social media and to encourage their followers to do so too for fear that their online excesses may come back to haunt them some day.
McConnell on Tanden: She’s excessively partisan. She tweeted frequently….
McConnell on Trump’s tweets: I think a lot of my members chose not to comment of the President’s daily tweeting. I was among them and we concluded that was not a constructive use of our time. pic.twitter.com/OlpSHLIQvb— Acyn (@Acyn) February 25, 2021
Join the conversation as a VIP Member