In the Internet age, when the world’s eyes are upon Russia, we’re all amateur Kremlinologists.
And since amateurs typically don’t understand the full complexion of the information we’re seeing, we tend to overreact to what may be innocuous developments.
So bear that in mind as you process the following tweets.
A number of private jets were spotted leaving Moscow for Dubai this morning. Which makes sense: After Putin’s nutty speech yesterday about cleansing Russia of pro-western “traitors,” if I were a Russian billionaire I’d want to get as far away from Moscow as I could ASAP.
A large exodus of private jets out of Moscow towards Dubai this morning too. pic.twitter.com/pJzXPtyQOu
— Oliver Alexander (@OAlexanderDK) March 17, 2022
But it’s not just private jets that are on the move, it seems:
Exodus of Russian Special Flight Squadron planes from #Moscow, all flying towards east #UkraineRussiaWar pic.twitter.com/pQgSMCpJGG
— MilitaryLand.net (@Militarylandnet) March 17, 2022
Several aircraft of Russia's 'Special Flight Squadron' which is dedicated to the transport of officials of the Russian government are active this morning over Russia.
At least 6 aircraft are currently visible on flight tracking sites. pic.twitter.com/AjmfLaUZ9Q
— Kyle Glen (@KyleJGlen) March 17, 2022
One outlet claims that one of the jets is a mobile command post:
This turned around very quickly. Our initial estimation with all these none routine flights is some people have been moved from Moscow today for some reason, possibly contingency operations or strategic requirements or meetings? 👀👀
— The Cavell Group (@TCG_CrisisRisks) March 17, 2022
Is Putin planning something that might give him and his advisors good reason to not want to be in Moscow when the west retaliates?
Before you panic, note that some of these flights might be picking people up and bringing them *to* Moscow. The planes are scheduled for return, in any case:
Difficult to know if this means anything, but some of these flights appear to be returning to Moscow, so maybe people are getting picked up for something happening in Moscow? https://t.co/jxHn6rXapc pic.twitter.com/Bh97a6KEFx
— Eliot Higgins (@EliotHiggins) March 17, 2022
It’s also curious that they’d leave their transponders on, broadcasting their movements to the world, if Putin were planning a surprise escalation. Maybe this is choreographed saber-rattling by Russia, an attempt to spook the U.S. and NATO into fearing that something big is coming. The timing would make sense, coming just a day after Biden announced we were sending a huge new weapons package to Ukraine.
In fact, at least one source says the movement of the Russian planes isn’t that unusual. Their flight paths may be a product of so much foreign airspace having recently been closed to Russian jets:
I had this discussion many months ago with a close friend about these kinds of mass plane spot posts. Prior to the war starting, a lot of it centered around how much was hype & how much was substance.
22 aircraft of the Russian Air Force and Rossiya – Special Flight Detachment. pic.twitter.com/tgTU4hPo7q
— Evergreen Intel (@vcdgf555) March 17, 2022
Now some of those Rossiya flights are returning to Moscow or have already arrived.
This behavior happens EVERY DAY. The only thing that has changed is their direction, starting off towards the east, due to air restrictions.
In short, I wouldn't run off to your bunker over this. pic.twitter.com/3QbpQvYfQL
— Evergreen Intel (@vcdgf555) March 17, 2022
That’s a relief! But wait — one particular plane’s unusual movements are harder to explain:
Lavrov was halfway to Beijing last night when his plane turned around abruptly and returned to Moscow @BILD reports. Unclear if Putin called him back or Chinese side got cold feet https://t.co/f9cCJBVSfY
— Noah Barkin (@noahbarkin) March 17, 2022
Did China decide it doesn’t want any photo ops right now? If so, one would think they would have communicated that to Lavrov before he left.
It seems more likely that Putin abruptly decided he needed Lavrov back in Moscow. And it must have been important business to justify canceling a trip to Russia’s one last meaningful ally mid-flight.
Or, a third possibility: There’s a power struggle suddenly unfolding in the capital and Lavrov’s presence was urgently needed.
Coincidentally, rumors are swirling that a top military official has been detained by the FSB:
Three independent sources report that the deputy chief of Russia's Rosgvardia (a unit of RU's interior army which has had tremendous losses in Ukraine), Gen. Roman Gavrilov has been detained by FSB. Gavrilov had also previously worked in FSO, Putin's security service.
— Christo Grozev (@christogrozev) March 17, 2022
While it's hard to guess what exactly the purge/reshuffling at the top of the siloviks will result in, one thing is clear: it's doubtless that Putin recognizes the deep s**t this operation is in. I.e. it's so bad that he changes horses in midstream – a big no-no during war.
— Christo Grozev (@christogrozev) March 17, 2022
A subsequent report in Russia media flagged by Grozev claims Gavrilov has been fired. He wouldn’t be the first Russian official purged within the past week over the fiasco in Ukraine, if so.
Tom Nichols is an expert on Russia who began his work during the Reagan era, in the thick of the Cold War. He’s watching the flight information today too but it’s not setting off any alarm bells. “I don’t know what it means,” he confessed on Twitter an hour ago. There have been no news reports suggesting that anything’s up either, which makes “social media panic” the likeliest explanation for what’s going on. Still, Lavrov’s movements are curious. And the White House is sufficiently concerned about Russia using WMD in Ukraine that Jake Sullivan formally warned Russia’s national security advisor in a phone call yesterday to think twice before doing it.
Hope for the best. Maybe the flights are nothing more or less than Russians, including Russian government officials, looking for a way out of the country? There’s a lot of that going around lately.
Join the conversation as a VIP Member