Emphasis on “at least.” A few of the iffiest Republicans, like Lisa Murkowkski, Bill Cassidy, Shelley Moore Capito, and Rob Portman, haven’t shown their cards yet.
If they want a vote on the final bill by Thursday, they need a vote on the motion to proceed today. Is that happening?
Both Dean Heller and Rand Paul have said they won't vote on the motion to proceed to the health bill. McConnell can only lose 1 more.
— Jonathan Weisman (@jonathanweisman) June 26, 2017
Mike Lee's spokesman tells me: "Lee will not vote to proceed to a bill he can't support."https://t.co/eGe2fSyA09
— John McCormack (@McCormackJohn) June 26, 2017
New: @RonJohnsonWI just told me if senate gop leadership insists on moving to h care this week he will vote against motion to proceed.
— Dana Bash (@DanaBashCNN) June 27, 2017
I want to work w/ my GOP & Dem colleagues to fix the flaws in ACA. CBO analysis shows Senate bill won't do it. I will vote no on mtp. 1/3
— Sen. Susan Collins (@SenatorCollins) June 26, 2017
Technically there are also five declared Republican “no” votes on the bill itself — but not the same five as above. Ted Cruz has said he can’t vote for the bill in its current form but hasn’t weighed in yet on the motion to proceed. Presumably he’ll also vote no on the MTP since he and Lee tend to vote together on these things. Likewise, if Collins is a no on the MTP, presumably she’s also a no on the bill in its current form. That means McConnell has already lost six Republicans when he can only afford to lose two.
Can he claw back four and keep Murkowski et al. happy? Maybe. He’s got money to play with.
Given that CBO says this reduces deficits by $321 billion, seems very likely they'll throw more money at centrists in coming days.
— Philip Klein (@philipaklein) June 26, 2017
Right, but how do you throw another $100-200 billion at the bill without alienating fiscal conservatives like Paul, Lee, and Cruz? The first two would almost certainly vote no if entitlements under the bill start to re-inflate; Cruz is trickier because he’s up for reelection and might find it hard to explain to Texans that he was the deciding vote against a bill that would have finally repealed ObamaCare. A Twitter pal, remembering Cruz’s slipperiness on the Gang of Eight bill four years ago, probably has it right: “Calling it now: Cruz will vote yes, then in 2020 will create an elaborate story about poison pills to justify his vote.” Heh.
Speaking of poison pills, one way out of this mess for McConnell is to promise to hold an open amendment process on the floor if the motion to proceed passes and let Republican skeptics offer their own proposals on ways to improve the bill. But that’s risky since something might pass that ends up making 50 votes on the final bill impossible. E.g., Collins could propose to cut the Medicaid rollback in half; all Senate Democrats would vote for that plus multiple Republicans. But on the final vote for the bill, Democrats will vote no en masse along with many Republicans who can’t support a bill that now includes Collins’s amendment. Result: The bill fails dismally. That’s why McConnell has been holding off on opening up the amendment process. But now he may not have a choice.
The entire GOP caucus is meeting for lunch today. If it looks like they don’t have the numbers for a motion to proceed, McConnell will likely postpone consideration of the bill until after the July 4th recess. That’ll give him more time to work on improvement — but it’ll also give Democrats time to organize pressure tactics on wary Republicans over the recess. If you’re in the camp that believes McConnell is an insuperable strategic genius who will somehow find a way, note that according to CNN’s sources the GOP leadership was caught off-guard by last night’s dam-break on the motion to proceed. “We’re hanging by a thread right now,” said one aide. Stay tuned.
Join the conversation as a VIP Member