Fifty years of failing America’s mentally ill
According to multiple studies summarized by the Treatment Advocacy Center, these untreated mentally ill are responsible for 10% of all homicides (and a higher percentage of the mass killings), constitute 20% of jail and prison inmates and at least 30% of the homeless. Severely mentally ill individuals now inundate hospital emergency rooms and have colonized libraries, parks, train stations and other public spaces. The quality of the lives of these individuals mocks the lofty intentions of the founders of the CMHC program.
Perhaps the most remarkable aspect of this 50-year federal experiment is its inordinate cost. In 2009, 4.7 million Americans received SSI or SSDI because of mental illnesses, not including mental retardation, a tenfold increase since 1977. The total cost was $46 billion. The total Medicaid and Medicare costs for mentally ill individuals in 2005 was more than $60 billion. …
Nor is President Obama likely to do anything, since his lead agency, the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration, has essentially denied that a problem exists. Its contribution to the president’s response to the Dec. 14 Newtown tragedy focused only on school children and insurance coverage. And its current plan of action for 2011-14, a 41,000-word document, includes no mention of schizophrenia, bipolar disorder or outpatient commitment, all essential elements in an effective plan for corrective action.









Blowback
Note from Hot Air management: This section is for comments from Hot Air's community of registered readers. Please don't assume that Hot Air management agrees with or otherwise endorses any particular comment just because we let it stand. A reminder: Anyone who fails to comply with our terms of use may lose their posting privilege.
Trackbacks/Pings
Trackback URL
Comments
We’ve allowed them to decide the last two presidential elections. Isn’t that enough…?
Kent18 on February 5, 2013 at 8:53 AM
I remember when the Agnew State Mental Hospital was closed, and the homeless schizophrenics started to populate downtown San Jose. Even the casual observer would notice that something was terribly wrong, but the federal government is not a casual observer and saw nothing.
claudius on February 5, 2013 at 9:06 AM
How about:
1. A public admission that the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration has failed
2. Dissolve it, terminating all of the bureaucrats immediately
3. Send the responsibility back to the states and local communities where any rational person can see it belongs
visions on February 5, 2013 at 9:13 AM
Failing them? democrats elect them to office at every level where they use the power to enrich themselves and their cronies while using their power to punish their enemies.
tom daschle concerned on February 5, 2013 at 9:13 AM
For decades there was a state mental facility called Fairfield Hills in Connecticut. The Leftists at the ACLU successfully had it shut down.
It was located in Newtown.
Del Dolemonte on February 5, 2013 at 9:16 AM
We’ve had politicians for longer than 50 years.
Bishop on February 5, 2013 at 9:34 AM
But yes, we have failed the entire state of Wisconsin….not that they’re worthy of much effort, mind you.
Bishop on February 5, 2013 at 9:34 AM
Basically the libs have experimented and used the Mentally ill and the mentally retarded. Both of those systems, like our military, are being used for great social experiments. There are advocates right now out there demanding we eliminate the word “diagnosis” from our vocabulary. Why is it that libs always want to eliminate words?
I was in a meeting many years back, about the closing of a hospital for the MR. The hospital was going to be closed down and all of the residents, regardless of the severity of their MR, would be placed in community living situations. In these hospitals the residents had complete safety. They had the run of the grounds. It was an isolated rural hospital. Many of the residents were used to walking from building to building on their own. On site, there were nurses, doctors and all the medical equipment needed for emergencies.
Now, I remember a particular meeting about a particular resident who was highly dangerous, hard to control and frequently roamed. this individual had enough Haldol in him alone to knock out 5 adults for a week… but it was just one of many drugs he was on. He was a dangerous individual. Had a history of running out of buildings into the courtyards and such… but the staff were used to him and the hospital grounds were safe for him.
But elitists utopians had other plans. They placed him in a community setting.. because that’s what their ideology called for. To the elitists utopians, there is no such thing as MR. Mental retardation is another group of words they want to get rid of. In fact, in that agency now, stating the word “retardation” is considered abusive. These individuals have been abused by the hospital system and need to be set free and have a normal life just like you or I. So you can live in a house, this individual should be able to also. Sounds so wonderful doesn’t it.
Well.. that individual ran out of his house and into the street several times a week. Endangering himself and others. He was a constant threat to the neighbors and himself. Breaking walls and windows, etc. Hurting staff. He had been transported often to the ER. Because that was the answer for the community system…. we don’t need nurses and doctors and specialized equipment on location.. we have 911 and the ER.
The strain that has been placed on the ER is so very real. That was the SOP for everything in the MR system. A resident falls back onto a couch, their head lands on a pillow.. 911 must be called and the individual taken to the ER.
In that same hospital meeting about another resident who was MR and also had severe physical limitations. Was frequently attended to by doctors and nurses. Hospital staff would ask the head of our committee.. “This individual needs A, B or C… how will you care for her?” Our committee leader would respond.. “We will call 911. She will be transported to the ER.”
We don’t need new fixes. We need to go back to what worked. But I don’t see that happening anytime soon. Our government is too corrupt and we lack men of courage and vision on our side. It will only get worse.
But I will bet my last paycheck on this one thing... as we continue to “normalize” retardation and mental illness and push community placement for dangerous sick individuals…. the same corrupt system is going to continue to treat sanity and innocence as sick and dangerous.
The same people who would push to free a dangerously retarded or mentally ill adults into community living will be the same system that will lock up a normal sane man who works 40 hours a week, doesn’t break any laws and loves his family.. but believes in the right to own a gun and carry a Bible.
JellyToast on February 5, 2013 at 9:37 AM
Don’t forget to thank the left. In particular the ACLU.
Bmore on February 5, 2013 at 10:23 AM
The damage from 0-care is still being rendered.
Bmore on February 5, 2013 at 10:24 AM
What treatment? There is no treatment. We don’t have the slightest clue how to treat mental illness. We can give people drugs that make them a bit saner (and make them feel like crap, which is why compliance is so poor outside supervised facilities). That’s about it.
I agree that the severely mentally ill belong in secure facilities, but there is simply no way those facilities will be anything other than a nightmare. How could it be otherwise? You can paint them yellow put house plants in them, but they’re still going to be locked wards full of unhappy crazy people.
Sometimes, all the available answers are tragic.
S. Weasel on February 5, 2013 at 10:42 AM
I worked in a similar place in SE New York. The place even had “Village” in its name. The residents worked there, lived there, had there own community center, dining hall etc. They were able to socialize, and had all necessary support RIGHT THERE. Over the past twenty years the goal has been to “integrate” them into the community at large in houses apart from each other. Now they are prisoners of the houses they live in, and hardly ever go outside. Loneliness and depression are endemic. Anyone who really cared about these souls would never have done this to them.
teacherman on February 5, 2013 at 10:51 AM
Conservatives need to look up what Reagan did to federal spending on mental health facilities in this country. One of the most shameful parts of a shameful presidency.
libfreeordie on February 5, 2013 at 11:26 AM
It goes back to a Supreme Court decision around 1972. There is nothing to be done until that is changed. The mentally ill are a small portion of the population and should be taken care of long before any other welfare programs. But they are more valuable on the street as a never ending issue for progressives.
CW20 on February 5, 2013 at 11:30 AM