How TV undermined the GOP’s family values pitch
Today, of course, we need only look at the popular sitcom Modern Family for an indication of just how much the idea of family has changed. That one family, which includes divorcées, immigrants, adopted children, gay couples, and strong women leading their households manages to encapsulate all the ways in which the definition of family has shifted and yet, remarkably, their arrangement is not unbelievable, nor does it stray too far from “traditional” family values. But what Modern Family doesn’t have is anybody who looks anything like a mainstream Republican: it’s difficult to imagine a character resembling Todd Akin, Rick Santorum, or even Mitt Romney appearing as anything other than a bumbling curiosity from an earlier age.
By showing what works for other—albeit, fictional—families, and by not heavy-handedly forcing values onto viewers, these shows both reflect the shift in Americans’ morals, while simultaneously pushing toward greater openness and acceptance of alternative family arrangements. Rather than downplay the role of family as its definition evolves, popular culture has shown us that family is as important as ever—so important, in fact, that people for whom the status of “family” has been denied will do anything to be included within it.








Blowback
Note from Hot Air management: This section is for comments from Hot Air's community of registered readers. Please don't assume that Hot Air management agrees with or otherwise endorses any particular comment just because we let it stand. A reminder: Anyone who fails to comply with our terms of use may lose their posting privilege.
Trackbacks/Pings
Trackback URL
Comments
Comment pages: « Previous 1 2
It wouldn’t be the first time I misunderstood what one was saying!
That said, whether one CAN live or CAN achieve a unified family or not may be based on image and distraction of values imposed on by external forces, real or imagined…not unlike your feeling of having “no place” for you or others in the same perceived situation. They may both be based on feelings more than actuality.
I say that because there seems to be 2 different ideas of the direction of many religious organizations…one is what you describe as being kinda of stuck in the past..and another is that they have become too detached from past principles and follow current relative and hipster values.
Mimzey on November 15, 2012 at 8:27 PM
Dear TigerPaw,
This thread is going away soon, so I’ll make this quick: I am an atheist, but hear what you say (and you have so much to say). Here’s hoping you find a Christian community that listens to you, the single woman. Best of everything.
Mrs. Smith
Ladysmith CulchaVulcha on November 15, 2012 at 8:29 PM
I don’t get how you think that you get to decide what the word Republican means and if you aren’t anti-abortion, anti-gay it makes you a squishy Democrat.
You right wing nuts can keep the word conservative but you are not really a Republican.
I don’t believe that the government should be in my business tell me what kind of lightbulbs to buy, that a business can’t sell plastic bags or has to buy their employees health insurance, or if they hire Jim to be their receptionist and the next day he shows up in heels, makeup and drag, the owner can’t fire him.
I don’t want the government favoring anyone, or telling me that I can’t think a certain way.
If you don’t see that America is changing and the children even in conservative homes are watching Modern Family then you can continue to live in the past.
Ricki on November 15, 2012 at 8:35 PM
Thank you but did you see my post?
I don’t like children and babies, so I have no interest in working around kids, so I wouldn’t want to work in a nursery, but that is about one of the only ministries a single Christian woman past age 30 is given to do or permitted to do in most churches.
Or maybe I mis read your post.
Finding a Baptist church or some other conservative one that permits a woman to do something that does not = “baby sit kids in nursery” is rare!
Read the book “Quitting Church” by Julia Duin.
Duin discusses this situation – her own experience as well as that of other women who did not want to do “stereotypical” women jobs, but their churches wouldn’t let them do anything else.
Duin is a journalist who also writes books. She likes kids (I do not), but regardless, if she volunteered for kid duties or non-kid duties at her church, her church would not let her participate.
She volunteered to play harp, read a book about childhood to a church group, etc., and all her overtures were turned down.
My overtures to my church were ignored as well.
My talents are in a technical field (nothing having to do with kids, baking, cleaning, or making cookies).
Some churches are so deeply mired in the sexism of the “traditional gender role” garbage, they won’t even let a woman lead a woman’s class for women about women’s issues – that has been brought up in books by Christians and blogs.
TigerPaw on November 15, 2012 at 8:36 PM
Thank you, Ladysmith. I wish the best to you too.
I am still a Christian, but after experiencing some very heartbreaking incidents the last few years, I turned to other Christians for support, and instead of receiving love and compassion, I was criticized or judged.
On top of that, I’m seeing how many conservative Christian churches are not fair and loving to people who don’t fit their assumed ideal of “married by 25 with a baby.”
Because my experience is also going on with a lot of other Christian women, I think it’s factual, not just my perception.
If you are married (I don’t know if you are), but if you are married, married people do not notice how singles past the age of 30 are slighted or overlooked by most conservative churches most of the time.
Almost all the sermons in such churches are about “making a stronger marriage” or “how to raise Godly children.”
So if you are over 35 years old and have never married or had kids, like me, what am I to take away from that unending sermon emphasis on marriage and kids, month and month, year after year?
The preachers will always use marriage as the one and only metaphor by which to explain God and how god relates to us in their sermons. There are other metaphors they can use, but that’s the one they often choose.
In addition to the book by Duin (“Quitting Church”) I mentioned before, there are other books that discuss this issue and ones close to it, such as one called “The Resignation of Eve” by Barna, I think.
I do not like “hipster churches,” actually.
The preachers of hipster churches are obsessed with drawing in new people under the age of 30.
This means Hipster Pastors get rock music played in their services, they wear “skinny jeans,” and they make every sermon about sex, because they are trying to attract younger groups. They think if they preach about sex all the time and wear hair gel, they will appear edgy and with it.
These are some of the same Christians who don’t give a hoot if they are hurting the feelings and excluding single Christians over 30 years old.
TigerPaw on November 15, 2012 at 8:46 PM
If the only thing you care about is “fiscal discipline” then that does not make you a Republican. It makes you a stingy Democrat, because you agree far more with the Democratic doctrine than you do the Republican which involves three things( national security, social issues, and fiscal conservatism.) SO yes that makes you at best a stingy Democrat. And if you think the same low information electorate is somehow going to swing to your side because you guaranteed them that Repubs won’t take away their abortion; you are sadly mistaken, but be my guest. If trying to be liked by your liberal friend is the shiny thing you wish to attain-have at it.
Yeah and I believe the reverse- that just because Jim wants to show up in heels; his employer doesn’t have to offend their clientele because he has a ‘preference.” I ACTUALLY believe in freedom of association, and know that protecting something as complex and as self-identifying as sexual preference will lead to a Constutional boondoggle. I also don’t think the states have to recognize every Tom, Dick and Harry’s relationship especially if the ELECTORATE doesn’t want it. And it wasn’t socons who took the power away from the states when it came to abortion, but keep falling for the “shiny things” that Dems sell you. And it certainly isn’t socons who are trying to take the power away from the states when it comes to marriage.. It is people like you who think I am a right wing nut while you have glowing review regarding your liberal friends whose party is actually raping this nation with or without an abortion.
Yeah I see America changing but it is more about “free stuff” than which two guys get to marry. Because in the scheme of things that only affects 3% of the population.. Abortion probably a little more. And if you don’t see that if you are willing to compromise the core of the Republican party to win, then the same politicians would be willing to compromise the fiscal principles as well.
melle1228 on November 15, 2012 at 8:56 PM
….or, choose to live in the future where the fallacy of those values are shown to be the facade that they are.
Why adopt the drunkards rationalization of “there can no longer be a life without drink…its just unrealistic to try”?
Mimzey on November 15, 2012 at 8:58 PM
How are we slighted?
Its a reality that people who live one experience sometimes cannot understand the path of others, but that doesn’t mean they ‘slight’ those people. There are just different life experiences.
My point is that the perception may be unduly focused on religion.
The same experience can be perceived in everyday social gatherings in which most people have families and children, and the talk, the experiences, the plans, and the values seem somewhat disjointed and alienating from someone with neither of those experiences in life.
Mimzey on November 15, 2012 at 9:08 PM
Yeah either I didn’t communicate it well or you didn’t read it well. The Baptist Church my husband attends DO NOT relegate single women to the nursery. It seems to me that you have a couple of bad experiences and now think that all of these Conservative Churches are like this bad experience. I am not going to change your mind and try to convince you that when your associations are bad then you find new associations. Good luck with your spiritual journey and I hope you are able to connect with the type of people you are looking for.
melle1228 on November 15, 2012 at 9:13 PM
But Christians are not to ignore or slight other people on the basis of marital status, money, or anything else. We are all equal in Christ. They are to show hospitality equally.
Many Christians act like being married is better or more holy than being single, and marriage and sex (and/or having babies) are often held up to be “the prize” and highest life goal a Christian can achieve.
The Bible teaches that singleness is equal to marriage, but this goes ignored by most conservative Christians who are totally consumed with marriage and protecting it from the “attacks by liberal secular culture”.
This means instead of looking to what you have in common in Christ, when you as a single (non married) walk into a new church, instead of caring about who you are in Christ, what career you have, etc., the first thing they want to know is, “Are youmarried with kids?,” when you say “no, never,” they quickly lose interest and drop you like a hot potato.
At most conservative churches, it doesn’t even get that far – you will usually be totally ignored by 99% of the church people in attendance unless you walk in with a man on your arm. Most singles notice this discrepancy. This is not just me, other singles have gone through this too, and Duin mentions it in her book.
I don’t think you are getting it: it’s not just me.
There are a TON of other Christians my age who have never married or are divorced that have experienced the same exact discrimination or shabby treatment, both in regards to marital status and gender or a combo of both.
You can find their stories all over the web, and in Christian books about these topics. It’s not just me.
It’s on record that church attendance has been shrinking the past ten or more years, and I am telling you one reason it’s shrinking.
Some who have blogs about spiritual and child abuse in the church theorize another reason is the rise of authoritarian teachings, too much spiritual abuse, and cover- ups of child abuse (in Baptist and Protestant Churches too, not just Roman Catholic).
Again, if you are married with a child, you are going to be oblivious to this phenomenon of how churches ignore the needs of singles over the age of 30, in particular the single females.
If you want numerous examples of how conservative churches slight singles over the age of 30 and you want examples of how they do this, you can find plenty of examples on forums and sites for Christians, where Christian singles over the age of 30 talk about their negative experiences.
In addition, the chapter on singles in the book “Quitting Church” by Julia Duin, and the first half of the book “Singled Out: Why Celibacy Must Be Reinvented in Today’s Church by Christine Colón and Bonnie Field Singled Out” contain many examples and interviews with such people.
There are also Christian books, sites, and blogs which have numerous examples of how churches slight Christian women (both married and singled), or treat them badly. Duin has one chapter in her “Quitting Church” book about that topic alone.
Christians who are married with kids tend to be oblivious to how the church ignores or insults singles over the age of 30 because 99% of church sermons and functions cater to them and their concerns and needs – unless those married Christians did not marry until they were much older (over 35 or 40), but Christians who married prior to 35 or 30 are blind to this.
Most sermons, Christian blogs, magazines, and Christian television programming assumes all or most Christians watching are already married with kids or will be. If you do not fall into that demographic, you will pretty much be ignored.
TigerPaw on November 15, 2012 at 9:58 PM
You make some fair points but it’s also worth re-iterating that there really are a whole array of churches out there and it’s probably worth having a look at a few of them.
The spectrum is incredibly wide. It makes an utter mockery of the GOP claiming to be a broad church.
CorporatePiggy on November 15, 2012 at 10:55 PM
Comment pages: « Previous 1 2