The Real Meaning of NBC's Staff Revolt

But over the past generation, huge packets of power have transferred from those bosses to their workers. This shift — made palpable this week by NBC News’ abrupt dismissal of former Republican National Committee Chair Ronna McDaniel after NBC News reporter Chuck Todd and the newsroom protested her hiring — has dramatically altered newsroom dynamics.

Advertisement

“In 35 years of covering the media, I have never seen a newsroom revolt like the one at NBC/MSNBC,” tweeted press critic David Zurawik. It was a little bit of an overstatement, but what is true today is that top editors, who once assigned and published pieces, hired and fired journalists, and set newsroom policy with minimal pushback from the staff, now face wild uprisings if they steer a course that riles enough newsroom employees. The bosses haven’t lost control, but they’re no longer completely in charge, and that is changing the way journalism gets done.

Ed Morrissey

I'm still in fire-breathing mode on this issue, but Shafer provides a good, balanced, contextual, and informative read from inside the industry. Shafer has been critical of these newsroom revolts in the past (especially in the Williamson/Atlantic incident), and sounds skeptical about this one as well. But he has the patience and detachment to give us a more objective view.

For my part, I agree with Daniel Okrent and the other editors Shafer quotes later in the essay. But I'm glad to get the perspective Shafer offers here, too. 

Join the conversation as a VIP Member

Trending on HotAir Videos

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement