Green Room

Hm: Should Republicans put forth Simpson-Bowles?

posted at 4:19 pm on November 30, 2012 by

Guy and I talked about this the other night, and I kinda like the idea, when compared to our other, dismal options at the moment. Hear him out.

Simpson-Bowles, for all its faults, was conducted in an open and transparent manner and brought disparate political players into a room to forge a serious compromise. It overhauls and streamlines our byzantine tax code, takes some important first steps on entitlements, and reduces and caps federal spending. On substance, I’d wager that it would be considerably better than anything Obama and Boehner might produce after weeks of behind-closed-doors acrimony with the proverbial gun to their heads. Politically, it paints Democrats into a tough corner. Republicans could make a grand show of reluctantly supporting Simpson-Bowles for the betterment of the country. Ideally, the press conference would be led by Paul Ryan, who might explain why he voted against the plan as a commissioner, but is now willing to set aside some of his strong ideological preferences to move the nation forward. They would remind viewers that the proposal they’re now backing only exists because President Obama specifically and publicly asked for it. Plus, more Democrats than Republicans voted for it, including Harry Reid’s top lieutenant in the Senate. Put simply, Simpson-Bowles represents the very embodiment of bipartisan collaboration and problem solving — precisely the sort of thing “moderates,” the media, and the public are always demanding. It would be exceedingly difficult for Democrats to paint the plan as radical or draconian in light of the commission’s origins and participants. The GOP’s “party of no” problem would also be hugely diminished; after all, they would have just signed on to the president’s commission, with the previously recalcitrant Paul Ryan magnanimously leading the way. It would be fascinating to watch the president and his allies try to denounce and reject the very proposal he called for.

There are things I don’t like about Simpson-Bowles, but here’s the thing. Simpson-Bowles was bad compared to the Ryan plan, which we are not passing in the near future. But it is far more responsible than what Obama’s offering at the moment, which is a total joke, and I can’t imagine you’ll get anything better for Republicans and conservatives even if Boehner and Obama did hammer out some grand bargain in the next couple weeks. The Left hates it, but Obama and Democrats have paid so much lip service to Simpson and Bowles being responsible and sober, they’d have trouble sidestepping this offer. The media would have trouble portraying it as unreasonable or Republicans as obstructionist (though I’m sure they’d try!). Cue the brutal Democratic infighting, which leads to what exactly? Obama repudiating his own commission’s plan in favor of some half-formed farce he came up with behind closed doors?

If it’s true that “Republicans are so screwed,” and liberals like Howard Dean think going over the cliff is the best deal for progressives, this is worth a thought or two. And, politics aside, I think it actually would be better for the country than going over the cliff or doing a horrible deal with Obama. All right, get to fighting in comments!

Update: There’s a big blog post on the main blog now, if y’all want to go comment there.

Recently in the Green Room:



Trackback URL


Comment pages: 1 2

Didn’t a few of the commission members try to force a vote on it?

“We don’t need no water.”

Steve Eggleston on November 30, 2012 at 7:24 PM

I think that many of us, including MKH and GB, don’t think that Obama and the Dems want SB to pass. It was purely a PR ploy on Obama’s part. It would have been a huge triangulation effort for Obama after the 2010 midterms and would have been something that Clinton definitely would have done. The best case scenario is that Simpson Bowles gets passed, which is vastly better than no spending cuts and giving Barry imperial power to raise the debt ceiling. Worst case scenario is we still go over the cliff; however, the Republicans don’t get blamed and they live to fight another day. It would be easy for the Rs to go on the Sunday shows and mention how they understand the election results and the need for compromise.

Illinidiva on November 30, 2012 at 7:38 PM

lester on November 30, 2012

sesquipedalian on November 30, 2012

…why do you folks talk to ‘brain dead‘ people?

KOOLAID2 on December 2, 2012 at 12:22 PM

Simply re-explain the Ryan budget plan and challenge the Democrats to come up with something better or shut up.

Meanwhile, just keep announcing over and over again that Liberals who can’t even come up with a Constitutionally-mandated budget have no business criticizing anybody else’s financial plans.

America needs serious fiscal reform. If Liberals don’t have a constructive solution, they are just stamping their feet and whining like children.

Republicans should challenge Democrats: “Lead, follow, or get out of the way!!!”

landlines on December 2, 2012 at 11:25 PM

There is no way Obama or the Senate will pass Simpson Bowles. About all the Republicans could do by passing it is exposé the Democrats for what they are, profligate spenders and anyone who has paid attention knows that already.

What the Democrats and the Press say we need is a balanced approach. Tax increases and modest budget cuts. We will get the tax increases and promises of future budget reductions.

It’s Lucy, Charlie Brown and the football all over again.

jpmn on December 3, 2012 at 7:48 AM

Comment pages: 1 2

HotAir — Politics, Culture, Media, 2017, Breaking News from a conservative viewpoint
Top Pick

Okay… you first.

Top Pick

“We should repeal it and replace, and we shouldn’t leave town until this is complete.”

“He feels like he is being thrown under the bus …”

“McCain has always been a fighter”

Ed Morrissey Jul 20, 2017 8:41 AM

“Cancer doesn’t know what it’s up against.”

They may be on to something

How capitalism averted the bee-pocalypse

John Sexton Jul 19, 2017 9:31 PM

“there are more honeybee colonies in the country today than in nearly 25 years.”

CBO releases estimate on Obamacare repeal

John Sexton Jul 19, 2017 8:31 PM

“The number of people who are uninsured would increase by 17 million in 2018, compared with the number under current law.”

Kasich: Fix Obamacare with more spending

Jason Hart Jul 19, 2017 8:01 PM

Ohio Gov. John Kasich wants Congress to “fix” Obamacare’s insurance exchanges with more federal spending

“This is a momentous decision.”

“One was told that she—her skin was too light and that she needed to listen to people of darker colored skin…”


Time off without pay for play

The new DOJ guidelines on asset forfeiture are obscene

Taylor Millard Jul 19, 2017 5:01 PM

Guilty until proven innocent.

“We’re just wondering what happened there.”

“This is an attempt at a political intervention.”

The blame game

“Inaction is not an option.”

“You have no feelings. You Christians are all racists.”


It would at least be a start

Noor lawyers up — for good reason.

Still losing ground.

Still an unusual choice

Lone Star blues

“…held in full view — but not listening distance — of others present.”

“In 1977, Chesimard was found guilty of first degree murder…”

“Shep is a friend, I like him, but he’s so anti-Trump.”