Green Room

Louisiana Sues Federal Government Over Illegal Aliens

posted at 11:05 am on November 16, 2011 by

We count illegal aliens in the census, and that is a good thing because we need to know just how many people are here illegally. But we should not count them for the purposes of apportioning Congressional districts. Because the federal government did just that, several states including Louisiana lost seats in the House. This week, Louisiana’s Attorney General Buddy Caldwell filed suit in the Supreme Court to get that seat back.

It’s not just the loss of a House district. Louisiana vs. Bryson (that’s John Bryson, Obama’s controversial Secretary of Commerce) points out that with the loss of the House district comes a reduction in electoral college votes.  As Lyle Denniston writes at Scotusblog:

The result of these disparities, Louisiana said, is that the votes of its citizens are worth less “in terms of electoral power” than in a state like California, with a large population of undocumented aliens.  Here is how that comes about, according to Louisiana’s lawsuit: a state with a small population of illegal aliens winds up with a greater proportion of eligible voters per district, because fewer of its residents are deducted from the voting population.  The state illustrated the point with these figures: 748,160 voting-age individuals in Louisiana will elect a Representative in each district in the state, while only 656,452 Californians are needed to elect a member of the House in each district in that state.  That is a nearly 14 percent decrease in Louisiana’s electoral power, the state said.

While the trend has been to move from labels like “illegal alien” to “illegal immigrant” and “undocumented immigrant” or even “migrant” this lawsuit puts the issue into sharp relief by identifying them as “Non-Immigrant Foreign Nationals.”  The case will decide whether we have the right to exclude non-citizens from our political calculations.  If we’re going to count them for those purposes, granting non-citizens voting rights is just a small step from there.



Recently in the Green Room:



Trackback URL


Jindal & company are demonstrating how it’s done!
_____/Jindal 2012!

itsnotaboutme on November 16, 2011 at 11:13 AM

Good luck LA, but the feds don’t have a good record helping the states out on illegal aliens!

letget on November 16, 2011 at 11:24 AM

How many would California lose? 5, 10 or 20?

Kermit on November 16, 2011 at 11:42 AM

Well, I didn’t think I’d be in favor of this suit, but it looks to have a good basis. Unfortunately, most suits of this kind just end up setting bad precedents by being decided in the wrong way. This one may do better than that.

J.E. Dyer on November 16, 2011 at 11:51 AM

If we lose the case – which is certainly possible even in the mildly conservative Roberts court – the political outcry is going to be a Bidenesque ‘big f*ing deal.’

That is, if the GOP has the testicular fortitude to make it so… So, yeah, never mind I guess.

Laura Curtis on November 16, 2011 at 12:02 PM

Good for LA. I hope more suits follow. Our federal government is turning into a government of, by, and for the people — of any nation but the U.S.

AZCoyote on November 16, 2011 at 3:16 PM

Well, I didn’t think I’d be in favor of this suit, but it looks to have a good basis. Unfortunately, most suits of this kind just end up setting bad precedents by being decided in the wrong way. This one may do better than that.

J.E. Dyer on November 16, 2011 at 11:51 AM

I don’t think we risk a thing here. The Supreme Court isn’t going to do anything beyond letting Obama have his way. And that loss won’t even matter much. A truly conservative Supreme Court is going to have defy precedent in a long list of cases, after the Left has been legislating from the bench for so long. They will find the way to overturn on this issue also.

thuja on November 17, 2011 at 11:47 AM

HotAir — Politics, Culture, Media, 2017, Breaking News from a conservative viewpoint
Top Pick

Well… most of the politics anyway

“It would be catastrophic if the President were to fire the special counsel.”

“The blockade breached institutional values of freedom of expression and assembly.”

“I hope to encourage them to take personal responsibility…”

“I ain’t serving no police”

“I think a lot of Trump’s voters have as one of their primary objectives just stopping the cultural corruption that’s taking place.”

“Don’t take away my health care or you die.”

“We must all do our best to get rid of this tyrant.”

Rosenstein: Comey broke with DoJ norms on memo leak.

“Nobody has ever accused me of pulling any weapon on them.”

“Fourteen people had stab wounds, cuts and bruises, with two of the injured surviving critical stab wounds.”

Okay… you first.

“We should repeal it and replace, and we shouldn’t leave town until this is complete.”

“He feels like he is being thrown under the bus …”

“McCain has always been a fighter”

Ed Morrissey Jul 20, 2017 8:41 AM

“Cancer doesn’t know what it’s up against.”

They may be on to something

How capitalism averted the bee-pocalypse

John Sexton Jul 19, 2017 9:31 PM

“there are more honeybee colonies in the country today than in nearly 25 years.”

CBO releases estimate on Obamacare repeal

John Sexton Jul 19, 2017 8:31 PM

“The number of people who are uninsured would increase by 17 million in 2018, compared with the number under current law.”

Kasich: Fix Obamacare with more spending

Jason Hart Jul 19, 2017 8:01 PM

Ohio Gov. John Kasich wants Congress to “fix” Obamacare’s insurance exchanges with more federal spending

“This is a momentous decision.”

“One was told that she—her skin was too light and that she needed to listen to people of darker colored skin…”


Time off without pay for play

The new DOJ guidelines on asset forfeiture are obscene

Taylor Millard Jul 19, 2017 5:01 PM

Guilty until proven innocent.

“We’re just wondering what happened there.”

“This is an attempt at a political intervention.”

The blame game

“Inaction is not an option.”