Rick Perry’s BIG Win!
posted at 10:26 pm on September 7, 2011 by Kevin McCullough
[ Elections ]

Center of Attention, Leading the Pack
There was much riding on the debut of Gov. Rick Perry in the conversation of the GOP race. A race he came to dominate in less time than any other candidate on the floor.
On display would be not only the aggressive, misleading, and flat out dishonest gamesmanship of Brian Williams of NBC and John Harris of Politico, but the attempts by the other candidates to present Perry as somehow not the guy equipped to run the country.
Couple this with the heart-wrenching circumstances he faces in he and Ron Paul’s home state with wildfires that have devoured more than 1000 homes, and Rick Perry was a man tonight besieged from every angle. The heart, the mind, the friend, the foe… all gunning for him, testing him, and seeing how he would fare.
What the nation saw was a man who thought before he spoke, chose words wisely, and in whatever moment he found himself in, someone who wasn’t merely able to be conversant about the issue, but penetrate the tone, spirit, and focus of the discussion that caused everyone else on the stage to respond… to him!
This would’ve been a win for Rick Perry just on the mathematical equation of judging debates. But considering the increased odds he was up against, the smoothness with which he won, translates into massive points of confidence of those already supporting him, and for those yet decided, his plain speak common sense drew them in.
Odds were this debate could’ve set up a huge battle between Romney and Perry kicking off with Romney landing damaging blows. That picture never happened.
Romney was basically defeated for the night when the discussion turned to Romneycare. His refusal to address the issue, and to pretend to change the subject to giving all fifty states waivers to Obamacare was deflated the moment Bachmann (who touted another strong performance) hit back with “overturn” not “waivers” is the only true solution.
Huntsman–who was given an ungodly amount of time to yammer on about essentially nothing, should be relegated to the ash-heap of 2011, as more or less Cain should be as well.
Just not enough substance, just not enough focus. And with the lightest resumes on the stage both should be sitting down.
WHAT ASTOUNDS ME about this GOP field is the articulate nature that everyone besides Huntsman and to a lesser degree Paul are able to exhibit. I believe Obama, on merits would lose a debate to any of the following: Santorum, Gingrich, Bachmann, Romney, and Perry.
That’s a very deep bench with this level of communication skill. And my only hope is that Gingrich was telling the truth tonight when he proclaimed that the entire stage wants so bad to see Obama beaten, that they would all immediately go to work for the eventual winner.
Whoever the nominee is to be, He/She will NEED that kind of support from such an articulate supporting cast. At the end of the day, Perry won–he won big, and is likely to add to those huge polling leads he has gained in recent days.
But perhaps you disagree–I’d love to know your response and perhaps read it on my nationally syndicated show tomorrow. Drop me an email to weigh in.
Kevin McCullough is a nationally syndicated talk radio host, FOX NEWS CONTRIBUTOR, and best selling author of three books. His most recent being: “No He Can’t: How Barack Obama is dismantling Hope and Change.”









Blowback
Note from Hot Air management: This section is for comments from Hot Air's community of registered readers. Please don't assume that Hot Air management agrees with or otherwise endorses any particular comment just because we let it stand. A reminder: Anyone who fails to comply with our terms of use may lose their posting privilege.
Trackbacks/Pings
Trackback URL
Comments
Herman Cain needs to ditch the double-breasted suits for starters.
I thought Perry was just okay. He wasn’t gang-busters like I thought he’d be. I did like his tendency to ignore dumb questions and go on with a theme.
I’ll give overall performance to Romney by a whisker, but both Perry and Bachmann finished strongly.
SouthernGent on September 7, 2011 at 10:50 PM
I was not quite as enthralled with Perry as you but I do agree on the majority of your points. Best line of the debate: Justice, Perry will be widely applauded and attacked on that line. Perry stood out and received more time because he was attacked. The person who gets attacked and has a good comeback, scores higher points with the audience then the attacker.
IowaWoman on September 7, 2011 at 10:59 PM
For the primary campaign, it’s hard to see how Perry loses ground to Romney on the Social Security issue if they’re going to keep going at it from their positions tonight (in fact, coming on the heels of his problem with the Republican base on Commonwealth Care, it’s not going to be a very tenable spot for Mitt if he’s going to become the candidate trying to scare seniors about having then benefits taken away).
However, for the general election, Perry’s going to have to present his option to reform Social Security earlier than for other GOP hopefuls, because he has made so much of its non-viability. And he’s better off providing at least the basis of a plan sometime before Iowa when he can still control the narrative, rather than waiting until later when Team Obama can define him (and the same holds true for any other Republican who might win the nomination — even Mitt would be demonized in the general election as trying to kill Social Security, so it’s better to be proactive and present an alternative sooner than later).
jon1979 on September 7, 2011 at 11:07 PM
Kevin.. nice bit of campaign spin here… you gunning for a spot on a possible perry administration?
gatorboy on September 8, 2011 at 12:06 AM
GatorBoy…
Where’s the spin? Please be specific…
Kevin McCullough on September 8, 2011 at 12:09 AM
Though I’m suspicious of Perry because I think he, like Bush before him, has a fundamental blindness to the mortal damage that the open southern border is doing to our nation, I thought his debut was stellar.
Perry was poised, forceful and focused. A formidable candidate.
Now the race is on!
cane_loader on September 8, 2011 at 3:53 AM
You are seeing this group ridiculously optimistically. Perry was weak in the debate, with no memorable lines and no policy ideas to speak of, but (thankfully) that weak-kneed fool Romney was worse. The rest of the dwarves were just silly. Santorum and Bachmann aren’t electable. Cain pushed a new national sales tax, so he’s history. Ron Paul isn’t even a Republican, so why must we listen to him?
This is a sorry group.
MTF on September 8, 2011 at 7:47 AM
That’s a little strong, isn’t it?
Perry won by not loosing. Of course he was the guy in the cross hairs. He knew it and his responses were adequate, for a start. He may have been busy and didn’t prepare as well as the others. That’s a point on his side, he usually doesn’t do so well when he hasn’t prepared.
If he performs as he has in the past, he will get better with each debate. He won this time by not loosing, or coming off as a fire breathing right wing religious dragon. He will need to do better at telling us what he is for.
cozmo on September 8, 2011 at 10:05 AM
Really? The dems are already splicing the “ponzi scheme” line for commercials.
The justice line will be remembered by both sides.
cozmo on September 8, 2011 at 10:07 AM
Interesting debate. Watched for the substance of each candidate’s views. I missed the first 20 mins or so, but if applause is any indication of scoring, think Perry won hands down. Bottomline, I can not, will not vote for a CINO in the general as the lesser of two evils. This excludes Mittness & Stardust off the bat.
AH_C on September 8, 2011 at 11:01 AM
Perry at times froze like he was a Mac with the spinning beach ball.
haner on September 8, 2011 at 12:05 PM
For the few missteps Perry may have made last night, they were all but forgotten when Rick delivered his “ultimate justice” answer.
Knucklehead on September 8, 2011 at 2:03 PM
This is silly! Perry was a total disaster! Romney was Romney. But Romney is so much better than Perry.
I expected at least to like the guy better. Perry lost a lot of ground. He will fade very soon. The media is just propping him up as a sheild to split the attacks from the lefties.
Romney won the nomination last night. Perry is Romney’s sheild right now.
petunia on September 8, 2011 at 10:10 PM
MTF:
Stop being so hard on Sarah Palin’s cabinet.
BemusedMalkinite on September 9, 2011 at 4:23 AM
BTW, could one of y’all tell 2 friends, then ask them to tell two friends, and so on, and so on, the difference once and for all between writing “losing” and “loosing”? We have enough problems with the left calling us stupid: there’s no need to hand them fresh ammo.
And sorry nothing personal but enough of this “well at least he didn’t come off as too right wing” horsesh!t. Americans WANT A LEADER who is passionate and stands up for what he/she believes in! Stop apologizing for being conservative! Moderates suck: Rush is the only commentator consistently alling them out for the cowards that they are.
BemusedMalkinite on September 9, 2011 at 4:27 AM
Alling, calling, whatever, time to call it a day. ABO 2012!
BemusedMalkinite on September 9, 2011 at 4:29 AM