Green Room

Erdogan: Ottoman echoes growing louder

posted at 6:05 pm on June 13, 2011 by

Recep Tayyip Erdogan’s Justice and Development Party (AKP) won a comfortable majority in Turkey’s parliamentary election on 12 June – not enough to change the national constitution without the agreement of a parliamentary coalition, but a solid 325 or so out of 550 seats, and a higher margin of victory than AKP achieved in 2007.

Erdogan wasted no time projecting a decidedly Ottoman-sounding theme in his victory speech.  According to foreign media:

In his victory speech, Mr Erdogan … alluded to Turkey’s aspiration to be a voice in the West for the Middle Eastern region and Muslims, saying Bosnians, Lebanese, Syrians and Palestinians also benefited from his victory.

“Believe me, Sarajevo won today as much as Istanbul, Beirut won as much as Izmir, Damascus won as much as Ankara, Ramallah, Nablus, Jenin, the West Bank, Jerusalem won as much as Diyarbakir.”

Imagine Nicolas Sarkozy proclaiming in a victory speech that Moscow had won as much as Paris, Washington as much as Lyon, Ankara as much as Marseilles.  Equally to the point, imagine David Cameron announcing that New Delhi had won, as much as London; Boston as much as York; Dublin as much as Leeds.

You can’t.  Because it is freighted wording – imperialist at worst, absurdly arrogant at best – to speak of your electoral victories as conferring benefits on foreign humanity – especially on those once occupied by your nation in its days of empire.

Granted, Barack Obama spoke in arguably similar terms after his election to the Oval Office.  He didn’t make the case explicitly, but there was an implied “Cairo won, as much as Washington” theme in his early speeches.  So you could make the case that he started it, if you wanted to put in the effort.

But Erdogan’s references are awful darn particular.  Sarajevo, Damascus, Beirut, Ramallah, and Jerusalem.  The tenor of his appeal is both Islamist and Ottoman – and, of course, from a historical perspective, the two go together.  The West’s most recent memories of Islamic conquest involve the Ottoman Empire, which controlled parts of the Balkans – gained in bloody wars of conquest and occupation – right up to the last years before World War I.

Sarajevo, in particular, was an emblem of Ottoman conquest, much as Cordoba, Spain was an emblem of conquest by the Muslim Umayyads several hundred years earlier.  Sarajevo’s Ottoman conquerors used the city as a capital from the mid-15th to the late 17th century.  Although they were driven out of it by Austria-Hungary in 1697, after their defeat at the “gates of Vienna” in the previous decade, Ottoman rule continued in much of the Balkans, including Sarajevo, for two more centuries.  Ottoman officials put down revolts mounted by Bosnian Serbs in the Sarajevo of the 1830s, and it was not until 1878 that Austria-Hungary wrested Sarajevo from Istanbul for good.  The Ottomans continued to rule parts of the Balkans until the First Balkan War in 1912.

Erdogan’s allusion to Sarajevo is the exact opposite of a throw-away line.  He knows perfectly well how incendiary the reference is for East Europeans – just as he knows that naming cities in the West Bank one after another, and concluding with “Jerusalem” (which he called Al-Quds), implies a direct Turkish interest in the disposition of these cities that evokes the era when they, too, were under Ottoman rule.

His rhetorical pairing of Ramallah and Jerusalem with Diyarbakir is of particular interest, considering that Diyarbakir is in a majority Kurdish area of Turkey, and regularly exploded in protest in the weeks leading up the 12 June election.  Many in Diyarbakir would disagree that Erdogan’s win was a win for them; his outreach gesture of allowing the Kurdish nationalist party to field candidates in this election resulted in several jailed Kurdish leaders, deemed terrorists by the central government, being elected to parliament.  Their status is unclear, and a number of observers think the electoral gains by the Kurds will only encourage them to press harder for autonomy.  But Erdogan’s going to “name it and claim it” anyway.  The implied signal to the Palestinian Arabs seems dubious, at best.

Perhaps most interesting of all is Erdogan’s list itself.  Sarajevo, Damascus, Beirut, Ramallah, Jerusalem.  In four of these former Ottoman holdings, there is, or has been, an acknowledged modern dispute over sovereignty.  But what about Damascus?  Should the Assads – or Iran – be alarmed that it was on Erdogan’s list?  Does Damascus need the healing hand of Erdogan and the AKP?  Or is Syria – but not Jordan, Egypt, or Iraq – considered by Erdogan to be properly in modern Turkey’s “sphere”?

The answers to these questions and others we will presumably discern in the days ahead.  But there he is, folks.  The new voice of the Middle East in the West – representing Muslims from Sarajevo to Jerusalem.

J.E. Dyer’s articles have appeared at The Green Room, Commentary’s “contentions,Patheos, The Weekly Standard online, and her own blog, The Optimistic Conservative.

Recently in the Green Room:



Trackback URL


I know very little of history and even less of the crusades but Erdogan almost sounds as if he would welcome the return of the crusades.

fourdeucer on June 13, 2011 at 7:03 PM

Has the Turkish military, the conservator of Ataturk’s secularism, been neutered?

NaCly dog on June 13, 2011 at 7:27 PM

Has the Turkish military, the conservator of Ataturk’s secularism, been neutered?

NaCly dog on June 13, 2011 at 7:27 PM

Erdogan’s been on that like stink on poo since he entered office. Look up “Sledgehammer” or Ergenekon conspiracy, and you’ll find info on the supposed 2003-era conspiracy the Erdogan government has been accusing the military of for the last several years. Dozens of senior military officers have been accused, investigated, and even arrested since 2008.

Erdogan got voters to approve a restructuring of the national supreme court in 2010 as well, a move that bsaically amounts to “pulling an FDR.” The court is to be enlarged considerably, so Erdogan can stack it and eliminate the independence of the judiciary, and its traditional adherence to the principles of Kemalist secularism.

His anti-free-speech campaign is directed at freedom of the press and freedom in the academy, two entities he has been systematically intimidating. He’s going after all the checks and balances in the modern society cultivated under Kemalist auspices, and alarming a lot of people because he’s been having success.

J.E. Dyer on June 13, 2011 at 8:14 PM

J.E. Dyer on June 13, 2011 at 8:14 PM

Thank you very much for that illuminating response.

So what I’m hearing is that Erdogan’s just one election away from being able to fundamentally transform a militarily powerful NATO ally into an Islamic expansionistic nation in search of reclaiming past glories, national boundaries and alliances notwithstanding?

NaCly dog on June 13, 2011 at 10:05 PM

Well, if nothing else, this will effectively persuade and frightened the Greeks to start getting their country’s financial problems fixed completely. They hate the Ottomans and there is nothing more they fear than to lose their country again to the Turks. Same deal with Armenia. The Kurds have a massive ax to grind against the Turks and so does the Russians. Poland, Romania, Hungary and Bulgaria as well as Austria had a history against the Ottoman Turks.For Western Europe, if you think that it’s citizens are happy about Muslims carving Islamic enclaves in their own countries, think again. If you want a 21st century version of progroms as well as massive Muslim expulsions in Europe and America, have Edrogan talk about the restoring the past glories of the Ottoman empire and start doing something about it.

I will not be surprise if the Turkish Army will stage a coup d e’tat in the next two years or so.

DinobotPrime on June 14, 2011 at 12:46 AM

HotAir — Politics, Culture, Media, 2017, Breaking News from a conservative viewpoint

Just a reminder: People will die

Allahpundit Jun 28, 2017 10:41 PM
Top Pick

“Whipped cream’s killing more people than ever before.”

Top Pick

Medicare for all?

“There comes a point where you gotta get off the crazy train.”

Poll: Dem voters glumly sticking with Pelosi

Ed Morrissey Jun 28, 2017 8:41 PM

Disaster ahead?

“When she left it, it was in better shape than it had ever been.”

Manafort, firm registers as foreign agents

Ed Morrissey Jun 28, 2017 6:41 PM

Better late than never?

Delivered as promised

“I would like to think that the president saved many innocent men, women and children.”

“The Russia investigation was by far the dominant topic…”

The merry little media war continues.

Criminal enterprise

Politico: Has the SPLC lost its way?

John Sexton Jun 28, 2017 3:01 PM

“The organization has always tried to find ways to milk money out of the public…”

Trump legal team backing away from Comey complaint?

Ed Morrissey Jun 28, 2017 2:31 PM


Time to get up and go to work, sir

CNN gets glum, defensive after resignations

John Sexton Jun 28, 2017 1:01 PM

“If Jeff lit himself on fire, it wouldn’t appease the pro-Trump media.”

Hmmm: FBI probing Russia-based anti-virus firm?

Ed Morrissey Jun 28, 2017 12:31 PM

“I wouldn’t put their stuff on my computer if you paid me.”

He works hard for the money…

It’s not a slippery slope. It’s a freaking avalanche.


Showdown: Sarah Palin vs the New York Times

Jazz Shaw Jun 28, 2017 9:21 AM


Credit where creditor’s due?

More flash than bang, but a very bad sign

“Felix was out on bond after threatening another public servant and has a history of making threats.”

Chaffetz: House needs housing allowances?

Ed Morrissey Jun 27, 2017 8:41 PM

“There are dozens upon dozens of members living in their offices, and I don’t know how healthy that is long term.”

“This isn’t going to get a lot cheaper, it can’t, it won’t.”

“…what we failed to achieve with votes, we would do with weapons.”

“[S]o dumb it’s amazing we even have to have the conversation.”

“It was not necessary.”

“You’re inflaming everyone right here right now with those words!”

“Trump’s people said, ‘We’ll be writing the speech that the President’s Audio-Animatronic figure will be saying.'”

Excuses, excuses.

Not really a “kill all the lawyers” scenario

4 pm ET!

“it has not taken serious steps to end its own complicity in trafficking, including forced laborers from North Korea.”