WaPo Columnist E.J. Dionne Needs a Civics Lesson
posted at 4:02 pm on March 1, 2011 by Howard Portnoy
Would that Washington Post columnist E.J. Dionne knew as much about civics as he seems to know about the history of the state of Wisconsin.
In his column yesterday, in which Dionne sides (spoiler alert) with public unions over their employers—the taxpayers—he enlightens his readers on the history of Wisconsin, which he notes has previously “been at the center of national agitation over the role of unions.”
I will spare my own readers Dionne’s history lesson and his de rigueur sanctimony over the plight of the downtrodden as the playthings of greedy corporate special interests and cut to the chase. Which for him is the declaration that Governor Scott Walker’s efforts to curtail collective bargaining by public unions is nothing more than a power grab. Writes Dionne:
What the unions are rightly resisting is a shift in the long-term balance of political power that undercutting collective bargaining would represent.
That point is debatable. One that is not comes several paragraphs later, when Dionne writes:
Last week Walker signed into law a bill that will require a two-thirds supermajority in the legislature, or a statewide referendum, to raise income, sales or corporate franchise taxes. Imagine if President Obama had insisted that a two-thirds majority be required to repeal his health-care law?
In fact, Obama is insisting that a two-thirds majority is required to repeal ObamaCare. Hasn’t Dionne ever heard of the presidential veto?
The question is intended as rhetorical, but I for one would love to hear Dionne’s answer.
- Inconvenient truth: Public workers earn more than private workers in 41 states
- WI Assembly passes bill limiting public workers’ collective bargaining rights
- Public unions vs. private unions: The hidden side of the debate
- Protesting Milwaukee teachers earn triple the city’s per capita income
- Obama joins the fray in Wisconsin: Governor says butt out
- The view from Wisconsin: Is the left willing to make sacrifices?
Recently in the Green Room: