Light Dawns on Marblehead
posted at 8:44 pm on August 5, 2009 by Dafydd ab Hugh
If it seems to you that voters are rudely beginning to awaken to the looming health-care catastrophe that is ObamaCare — then you’re right! At least, so sayeth that well-known bastion of the Vast Right-Wing Conspiracy, Quinnipiac University. (Note to liberals who might read this: That last sentence was a sarcastic jibe, not a fair characterization of that fine institution of higher yearning.)
In a Quinnipiac poll of “2,409 registered voters nationwide,” with an MOE of ±2%, here are some of the findings:
- By 57% to 37%, registered voters say Barack H. Obama should drop health-care reform if it would add significantly to the deficit.
- By 72% to 21%, voters think the Obamacle is lying to us about the looming deficits caused by ObamaCare.
(Quinnipiac phrases this more politely, of course: “By a 72 – 21 percent margin, voters do not believe that President Barack Obama will keep his promise to overhaul the health care system without adding to the deficit.” In other words, he lies in his teeth.)
- 39% say the plan will “improve the quality of health care in the nation,” but 41% say it will hurt the quality.
- More specifically, only 21% of voters think it will improve the quality of health care they, personally receive, while 36% think it will hurt the quality of care they receive.
Alas, this is yet another instance of the Democrats’ best friend… the argument, “It might hurt me personally, but I’m sure it must be helping somebody somewhere!”
I believe this fantasy of an invisible army of losers who must be helped — even at the expense of the very visible but silent majority of non-losers — is a direct result of the victim mentality so carefully inculcated into our citizenry from childhood, via relentless propaganda in the public schools. The result is a nation of people who think they, personally, can handle their own affairs better than the government can… but who nevertheless support a government takeover because of all those other people who are helpless.
At least in this case, the nays still outnumber the yeas anent ObamaCare; yet the discrepancy abides.
- By a 44% to 34% margin, voters think ObamaCare will hurt, rather than help the economy.
- By 42% plurality to a scant 18%, voters think ObamaCare will make their own, personal health-care more expensive; 33% believe it will make no difference in the cost.
- Even more astonishing — voters, by a whopping 66% to 6%, think ObamaCare will increase the taxes they pay. (23% think it won’t make a difference.)
The poll contains one ray of sunshine for ultra left-wing Democrats, such as Squeaker of the House Nancy Pelosi (D-Haight-Ashbury, 100%) and Senate Majority Leader Harry “Pinky” Reid (D-Caesar’s Palace, 70%), and of course the One himself. But even on this question, I believe the favorable response is based upon a fundamental misunderstanding:
23. Do you support or oppose giving people the option of being covered by a government health insurance plan that would compete with private plans?
Sounds like voters really like that terrible government “option” component… but wait, what exactly did respondents think they were being asked about?
Read the question again: “Do you support or oppose giving people the option…?” I submit the most likely way for respondents to interpret that question is each individual deciding for himself between the government plan or a private plan he has now – which is not how it will work, of course (as even President Obama has admitted).
Rather, the decision between the current private plan, a new private plan, or the government plan would be made, not by individual employees, but by the boss… and the deck will be stacked in favor of the government plan, giving employers monetary and regulatory incentives to drop their own company’s coverage and just pay the feds to do it.
Employees will be forced, willy nilly, to go along with the switch, regardless of their own choices. If a respondent hadn’t already heard this, he couldn’t possibly figure it out from the Quinnipiac polling question.
This would be a fairer and more accurate question that I wish they would ask:
Do you support or oppose allowing employers to drop the current private coverage of their employees in favor of a government-run health-care plan?
I suspect the answer to that question, making it clear that the choice belongs to the boss, not the worker-bees, would elicit a very different response from voters.
Still and all, excellent polling numbers from Quinnipiac. And more important, the trend is in the right direction; most of these questions were asked on a July 1st poll; and in every case, support for ObamaCare dropped significantly in one month, while opposition skyrocketed.
It appears that the more Democrats and the president explain their “reform” of medical-care coverage, the more they terrify voters. This actually bodes quite well for those of us who believe that in this case, the prescription is more deadly than the disease.
Cross-posted on Big Lizards…
Recently in the Green Room: