Green Room

I’ll Take The Tenth

posted at 2:05 pm on July 12, 2009 by

On the Northern Alliance Radio Network broadcast yesterday, Ed and I talked with Minnesota State Representative Tom Emmer (the interview is in the second hour of the UStream webcast).  Emmer is seeking the GOP nomination to run for governor in 2010.

But he wasn’t on the show to campaign – not just yet.  He was there to promote his latest legislative initiative, House File 2376 – also known as the Firearms Freedom Act.

And I think that there is genius in this initiative – not in reinforcing our Second Amendment right, but in re-establishing the Tenth.

Work with me, here.

Thirty years ago, the Second Amendment was practically dead in the United States.  Gun control was sweeping the nation.  The courts accepted a vapid and fraudulent interpretation of an otherwise-insignificant case as the primary legal precedent dealing with the Second Amendment.  The rights of the law-abiding hit ebb-tide by the mid-seventies.

And then a grass-roots movement germinated, and took hold; the grassroots – Americans who’ve always regarded guns as tools, rather than social statements – started fighting back.  And starting in the early 1980s, they started turning the tide – one vote, one town, one legislature at a time,

“Shall-Issue” concealed carry laws – which put the burden on the state to prove that the citizen should not have the ability to bear the arms they keep – are a useful bellwether.  In 1983, there were all of eight states with these laws.  But the movement – a force of workadaddy, hugamommy citizens who squeezed activism into their spare time between work and family – started organizing movements, city by city and state by state, to change the laws.  And now, 26 years later, 39 states are either shall-issue or have no restrictions on the law-abiding whatsoever; only two states (Wisconsin and Illinois, which has such a peaceful place) still pay unthinking fealty to the ideal that a disarmed, passive citizenry is best.

And this victory was won one voter, one street, one bill at a time.  From the “bottom”, “up”.

And Rep. Emmer’s bill – actually borrowed from similar bills that have become law in Montana, Tennesee and South Carolina – is part of a national, grassroots effort to start that same dynamic for the second-least-appreciated amendment in the Constitution, the Tenth.

The Tenth Amendment has fallen on hard times since the 1930’s; the Fed, operating under the cover of several key court cases, has been able to insinuate federal power into a range of places and subjects that would have made the founding fathers blanche.

(For the benefit of the Obama supporters in the audience, the Tenth Amendment reads “The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people,” where “the people” mean exactly what Heller says it means; you and I).

The overreach of the Obama Administration casts this effort into stark relief; it underscores the urgency of the mission.   The Tenth Amendment is supposed to help protect the people from gross overreach by the federal government.  The implications of a weak Tenth Amendment are obvious; the government can claim almost anything is “interstate commerce” as a pretext for regulation.

The benefits of a strong Tenth Amendment?  The implications everything from taxation to Roe Vs. Wade.

And I think the Firearms Freedoms acts being introduced in other states (as Emmers is being introduced in Minnesota) are a great way to marry the power, passion and grassroots savvy of the most freedom-loving people in America with the need to push government back out of huge swathes of American life, and to do to the Interstate Commerce Act what the Right to Keep and Bear Arms movement has done to Gun Control.

If you live in Minnesota – or any of the other states where the Firearms Freedom Act is under consideration – get on your phone, call your legislator, and let them know that the same groundswell of people that made Gun Control a third rail in American politics over the past several decades of trenchfighting is still out there, looking for more notches on its belt.

If you live elsewhere?  Your mission is clear; let your legislators know that the Tenth Amendment isn’t (overregulated, over-taxed) chicken-feed.

Cross-posted at Shot In The Dark

Recently in the Green Room:



Trackback URL


If you love the 2nd and 10th Amendments, check this out.
It’s a local talk radio show in Fairbanks,AK from Friday.

Gov. Sarah Palin is in the studio, and the first call in guest is none other than Ted Nugent.
Much Constitutional goodness here, worth a listen.

Brian1972 on July 12, 2009 at 3:01 PM

Is there a map that shows violent crime rates from 86-present that could be run simultaneously with the shall- issue map?

journeyintothewhirlwind on July 12, 2009 at 3:05 PM


Excellent link! I might have to post (at my blog, natch) about it.


Not that I know of. But it’d be an interesting project to put together some kind of animated comparison.


Mitch_Berg on July 12, 2009 at 3:23 PM

I just hope beyond hope most states will enact the 10th. Our bho and team, plus most of the elected in dc think they can dictate what we citizens in a state does. Our founding Fathers saw to it we citizens in a state would not be under the control of the fed. gov. They gave the states rights to govern their states. In less than eight months, the whole over 200 years is in the crapper and the states should just
‘go along’. Please, people don’t let us become what I fear we might become. It is happening so fast!

letget on July 12, 2009 at 4:33 PM