Will there be a “Wellstone effect” in Kennedy remembrances?

posted at 2:19 pm on August 28, 2009 by Ed Morrissey

Commentators looking at the various angles of political funerals have understandably latched onto one of the most notorious, but don’t recall exactly why it became so.  Politico reports that the apparent politicization of Ted Kennedy’s death has led conservatives to warn about (and perhaps to hope for) the “Wellstone effect,” which would drive voters to Republicans.  However, that ignores the elements that made the Wellstone memorial so outrageous, as well as the timing that made it so relevant:

While most prominent Republicans stuck Wednesday and Thursday to sober condolences — and several Republican operatives said it was too early to accuse Democrats of politicizing a sad moment — the conservative media, as well as some operatives, has seized on the whiff of politicization of his passing, recalling the bitter charges and countercharges that followed Sen. Paul Wellstone’s (D-Minn.) memorial service in 2002.

That service, a sometimes boisterous rally that included calls to carry on Wellstone’s political legacy and some catcalls for Republican speakers, turned the memorial into a central campaign issue, and many observers think the still-disputed event helped elect a Republican to fill his seat. …

Another leading conservative media figure, Sean Hannity, recalled the Wellstone memorial.

“Remember Paul Wellstone’s death? You know, ‘Let’s do everything for Paul.’ And we’re now being implored to get behind Obamacare because it’s what Ted Kennedy would have wanted,” he said, according to the liberal media monitor Media Matters, which is in turn suggesting that conservatives have crossed the line with allegations of politicization.

The H.S.A. Coalition, a lobbying group devoted to tax-free health savings accounts — championed by conservatives as a health care solution — warned supporters to “watch for the Wellstone effect.”

“The Democrats should remember their experience with the Sen. Wellstone funeral,” wrote the group’s president, Dan Perrin. “While I disagreed with almost everything Sen. Kennedy stood for, the MSM [mainstream media] subjecting the country to a Sen. Wellstone-type funeral experience, would be using him like a cheap suit.”

There is always a danger in waving the bloody shirt, of course.  Concocting a “do it for Teddy” campaign assumes that most people admired him, which may be an arguable proposition even now.  Hitching a bill to the memory of a politician for anything other than naming a building or an airport has a very limited appeal, especially on a bill as hotly contested already as ObamaCare.

But that wasn’t what made the Wellstone memorial so outrageous to Minnesotans.  Many people across the political spectrum felt saddened by his death, because Wellstone was seen as honest and open about his convictions, even if his politics were about as loopy as it got in the Senate.  During the memorial service, broadcast live to all Minnesotans just days before the mid-term elections, his allies in the DFL (the Minnesota version of the Democratic Party) went way beyond using it as a platform for Wellstone’s political point of view, which most if not all of us expected.  One of its chief organizers and speakers, Rick Kahn, demanded that Republicans drop out of the Senate race and concede it to Walter Mondale, who replaced Wellstone after his death.  He and other speakers berated Republicans who appeared at the memorial to pay their respects.  It was a complete disaster and offended many Minnesotans, and not just Republicans, for its mean-spiritedness and utter lack of graciousness.  Coming so soon before the election, it had an impact nationwide against Democrats, according to Mark Penn.

At least thus far, nothing proposed by the Kennedy family or by Democrats comes close to matching the crass spectacle of the Wellstone memorial.  The “do it for Teddy” meme is practically expected by voters, which is why it won’t have much effect; it’s too obvious a manipulation to work on anyone but the true believers, where it won’t count anyway.  The next election is not a few days away but fourteen months.  Even if speakers get out of hand at the service, which Democrats will probably work hard to prevent, the impact will have dissipated in a fortnight.

A “Wellstone effect” is probably nothing more than wishful thinking, but it’s equaled by the hope of a “Kennedy effect” on ObamaCare.  Unless Democrats get very, very stupid about it, the memorial will have little impact on anyone except the mourners — which is exactly how it should be.

Related Posts:

Breaking on Hot Air



Trackback URL


Wait, that was Coretta Scott King, not the Rosa Parks cite, argh, they did it then, too.

It really is in their nature but as I said, I think the Catholic services will help rein them in otherwise it would most likely be Wellstonian.

KittyLowrey on August 28, 2009 at 6:23 PM

Unless Democrats get very, very stupid about it,



Hawkins1701 on August 28, 2009 at 6:46 PM

Ask not what a Dead Kennedy can do for you, but what you can do in the name of a Dead Kennedy.

portlandon on August 28, 2009 at 2:22 PM

Well for starts, you could buy more of their albums!

pilamaye on August 28, 2009 at 5:08 PM

Yeah, “Holiday in Cambodia” came to mind.

KennedyCare will just be salt in the wounds of the ‘conservatives’. Great stuff!!

simplesimon on August 28, 2009 at 4:38 PM

If it’s so painful to conservatives, why haven’t those stalwart, er, progressives already passed it?

ddrintn on August 28, 2009 at 6:49 PM

Here is an account of Rosa Parks’ memorial as some blogger described…I’ll nab it to give an idea (GWB was not at this, I was thinking of the Coretta Scott King funeral when he was sitting right there as the insults came):

Remembering Rosa

Going through the news, her funeral yesterday — the third service in four days — lasted for eight hours. Wow. Could you imagine a Mass of Christian Burial going that long? Anyone interested can find video clips here. Clintons both, Sharpton, Obama, Jesse, Aretha, everyone was there.

Even Farrakhan got a speaking part.

Predictably, the speeches at the Parks funeral got political, and heavily so — this was a woman who, after all, fought a political battle as a woman of genuine faith and serene conviction.

Al Sharpton, who referred to the late civil rights warrior as “the Mother of the Nation,” brought the crowd to his feet in the midst of a meditation on the new, covert racism with a chiding of, “When you have a nation respond, looking for weapons in Iraq that are not there, but can’t see a hurricane in Louisiana that is there.”

Don’t know that blogger, grabbed it because it gave the flavor of how the left politicizes funerals and memorials.

KittyLowrey on August 28, 2009 at 7:59 PM