Did Christians win “American Idol” for Kris Allen?

posted at 8:12 pm on May 21, 2009 by Allahpundit

If they did, it’s the first big election they’ve won in a long time.

Mild-mannered Christian versus flamboyant gay star in a pageant setting? There’s something soooo familiar about this. Presumably this means Allen will be the tabloids’ new hate object, victimized by all appropriate smears and embarrassing family revelations pertaining thereto. Adam Lambert’s loss is Carrie Prejean’s gain!

“Adam has the potential to be a star so overall you could say he deserves to win,” Simon Cowell told Tarts on Wednesday afternoon. “But this is ‘American Idol,’ anything could happen and we could have an upset.”

And an upset for Cowell it clearly was — the outspoken judge was the only one not to give Allen a standing ovation when he was announced the 2009 winner as determined by a record-breaking 100 million votes…

According to an ‘Idol’ insider, support for Kris most likely surged over the last week when Danny Gokey (who was extremely open about his involvement with the church) was voted off and thus Christians turned their full devotion to Allen who epitomizes the all-American, talented and moralistic role model.

An alternate theory: In an age of economic panic, the public longs for the soothing presence of a soft-spoken dork with a guitar.

A better argument can be made that we had a moment—when 100 million people vote for something, it’s bigger than a singing contest—that harkens to back to Nixon’s Silent Majority speech 40 years ago. “There’s a certain restiveness in Americans in times of uncertainty,” top Democratic pollster Doug Schoen told me minutes after the Allen vote. “People may well make decisions that aren’t obvious and clear. They’re opting for a choice they think is safe, less risky.” In other words, with the economy roiling, the role of government shifting, the banking and auto industries in freefall, the definition of marriage in flux and a health-care overhaul on deck, many feel good dialing and texting on behalf of an aw-shucks strummer from Conway, Arkansas. Bob Dylan and The Jefferson Airplane made headlines in the ’60s, but Pat Boone and Henry Mancini sold more records…

There’s some good news in our data for those hoping to avoid a repeat of Nixon-era divisions. Yes, the Blue State/Red State correlations largely held up: 11 of the 12 states that delivered Lambert the most votes, based on the Daily Beast’s projections, went Democrat in 2008, while Allen overperformed in the Republicans’ states. But it was interesting to see how relatively competitive Allen ran in Pennsylvania and Massachusetts, while Lambert held his own in Texas and Georgia. The red and blue states might indeed already be Obama-era purple states, when it comes to music.

I’ve never watched the show but nearly all the chatter online that I’ve stumbled across held that Lambert was by far the greater talent. Tell the truth, “Idol” fans, did he get gypped? If so, why are they letting the public vote weigh so heavily in the final competition? It’s the California budget initiative redux: If you have people around who get paid to make these decisions, there’s no sense dumping it in the public’s lap at the moment of truth.


Related Posts:

Breaking on Hot Air

Blowback

Note from Hot Air management: This section is for comments from Hot Air's community of registered readers. Please don't assume that Hot Air management agrees with or otherwise endorses any particular comment just because we let it stand. A reminder: Anyone who fails to comply with our terms of use may lose their posting privilege.

Trackbacks/Pings

Trackback URL

Comments

Comment pages: 1 2 3

Anyone want to click on one of links above and tell me he can’t sing? Seriously?

JustTruth101 on May 21, 2009 at 9:27 PM

I clicked. I listened. My ears hurt. He can’t sing.

The right person won. End of discussion.

Norwegian on May 22, 2009 at 1:04 PM

They tried to great another false outrage here to attack christianity with no proof to back it up.

All year I hadn’t heard a thing about Kris being a Christian, on the otherhand they did mention Danny (the 3rd place finisher) as being one.

Also while Adam was a better vocalist he wasn’t a better singer. His record is going to be a mishmosh of BS so he can pretend to be something he’s not. No Rock fan would dare buy his record, he’d be a good Broadway singer, but even then he would never be in an alltime great play. Kris on the otherhand is much more sellable, he can take from the Jonas crowd and sing more then over-hyped musical theater songs.

Kris won not because he was religious, but because he was a better traditional musician (he played guitar and piano and altered the songs himself) while Adam was just a singer.

Rbastid on May 22, 2009 at 1:07 PM

1. Adam screams, not sings. He is NOT the better singer.

2. America is more likely to listen to a cd of Kris or hear Kris’ voice on a car commercial than shrieking mc-glam-glam

3. Arkansas contributed 38 MILLION of the 100 million votes. It’s the biggest thing here in years.

“undiscovered” Adam, btw, is already the lead understudy in the LA touring cast of Broadway’s “Wicked” — hardly someone that is an unknown.

AI used to be good because it found these random Clay Aikens or Carrie Underwoods — really really good SINGERS that never had any exposure or contacts. Adam has been doing this for years.

Bet on Kris. He’s still improving. Adam, however, has maxed out on his vocal abilities.

battleoflepanto1571 on May 22, 2009 at 1:36 PM

So, if Christians did in fact push Allen to the top, they did so because the other guy was openly gay.

That means they assume that because Allen is not openly gay he should win. Such might just prove that Christians aren’t the most intelligent creatures on Earth.

PresidenToor on May 22, 2009 at 3:34 PM

PresidenToor on May 22, 2009 at 3:34 PM

Your comments makes no sense and do not reflect the reality of what happened. While Adam seems like a nice person, his online pictures show that he is more than “openly gay.” Most gays do not engage in this kind of exhibitionism.

And Allen is not “openly gay” because he isn’t gay.

Maybe you should read all the comments here from other Christians like me and see why Kris won, instead of jump to silly conclusions. And instead of insulting us as being stupid.

And maybe the Christian vote was FOR a decent and talented Kris instead of AGAINST a talented and gay Adam.

Elisa on May 22, 2009 at 5:13 PM

Comment pages: 1 2 3