Hot Air Mobile
Home The Vault Gear About
Hot Air -- get your fill


Video: “No, Mr. President”

posted at 1:05 pm on May 18, 2009 by Allahpundit
Share on Facebook | printer-friendly

An amends of sorts to passionate pro-lifers who don’t care for my position on this issue. The speaker is theologian John Piper, the animator is unknown, but both are obviously superb at their jobs. Consider this an especially vivid illustration of the point I made yesterday about the impossibility of “open-mindedness” about abortion when one’s religious conviction runs this deeply. As Freddoso puts it in his postmortem of The One’s speech:

Notre Dame sent another clear message to its new graduates by honoring a politician who has spent his entire career resisting even the smallest legal protection for the unborn. To tomorrow’s Catholic leaders, Notre Dame has said that the direct and deliberate taking of innocent human life through abortion is just one issue among many, and nothing worth getting too upset about.

Indeed. The most important thing — the supreme virtue — is “dialogue.” No doubt Netanyahu’s getting an earful about that right now.


Blowback

Note from Hot Air management: This section is for comments from Hot Air's community of registered readers. Please don't assume that Hot Air management agrees with or otherwise endorses any particular comment just because we let it stand. A reminder: Anyone who fails to comply with our terms of use may lose their posting privilege.

Trackbacks/Pings

Trackback URL

Comments

Comment pages: 1 2 3

petunia on May 18, 2009 at 2:52 PM

:) One of the reasons why I decided not to go to BYU, was because even though I agree with the Honor code…I am such a rebel, I was afraid I would rebel against my own standards because someone in authority was dictating it.

Conservative Voice on May 18, 2009 at 2:56 PM

I actually went as a freshmen and that was back when you couldn’t wear denim on campus… I paid my rent at the administration building in overalls! I was such a rebel!

Seriously, I have warned my kids exactly what you said. Don’t focus on the authority issue! But do you agree with the honor code or not? I mean it is pretty much how we live everyday anyway. Three of my kids have gone to BYU. And they were fine. I think I’m more naturally rebellious than my kids.

petunia on May 18, 2009 at 3:09 PM

Um…aren’t adults also “clumps of cells” or does our matter change after birth?

thecountofincognito on May 18, 2009 at 3:34 PM

Amen

Buford on May 18, 2009 at 3:35 PM

…unimpeded and massive atrocities are worse than war. … It is as though you come upon a gang molesting an elderly woman. You have no idea whether intervention will save her or just double the casualties. All you know is: this cannot be left unopposed. I must try.

-John Piper

The world is an abnormal world. Because of the Fall, it is not what God meant it to be. There are many things in this world which grieve, but we must face them down. We never have the luxury of acting in a merely utopian way.

Utopian schemes in this fallen world have always brought tragedy. The Bible is never utopian. Authentically biblical morality, and not a non-Christian and romantic counterfeit, demands that people have our prayers – but not only our prayers.

From my own study of Scripture I would say that to refuse to do what I can for those who are under the power of oppressors is nothing less than the failure of Christian love. . . .

This is why I am not a pacifist. Pacifism in this poor fallen world in which we live – this lost world – means that we desert the people who need the greatest help.

-Francis Schaeffer

jp on May 18, 2009 at 3:38 PM

John Piper has been the pastor of Bethlehem Baptist Church in Minneapolis, MN for more than a quarter-century. When I first met him in 1989, BBC was a small urban church with barely a hundred members. It now has a membership in the thousands, on two campuses, with multiple services and a worldwide publishing ministry.

Piper’s un-watered-down message of the radical grace of Jesus Christ has not changed one whit since the day I met him. I have never met any other living person with a greater sense of humility, nor a greater, more palpable joy in knowing the Savior. He exudes passion for the Gospel like no one I have ever met.

His preaching is deeply exegetic – that is, he digs into the text to uncover its meaning, looking at the original texts (Piper taught Greek at the university level before being called to preach) and cross-comparing them to other Biblical and non-Biblical texts to uncover the author’s meaning. A running joke is Piper closing a sermon with, “I had ten things I wanted to say about this verse, but we only got through three of them. We’ll see you next week.” he preached through the Book of Romans start to finish – it took him four years.

I’m proud that John was my pastor for many years. He baptised me and my wife and officiated at our wedding.

skydaddy on May 18, 2009 at 3:40 PM

The problem with these things is that they are only powerful to people who already believe it. (preaching to the choir as it were)

If someone believes that it is only a lump of cells, then that’s that to them and saying it’s DEAD to them is like talking passionately about hair being cut.

The true test is does it change people’s minds.

Just as with any sin people will rationalize, half see facts, and subconsciously (yet intentionally) misunderstand points to make it all good. Just listen to what Obama says and what other libs say and you’ll see what I mean.

- The Cat

MirCat on May 18, 2009 at 3:41 PM

That video is a great example of why thinking people think religious people are nuts.

People like that are enough to scare the crap out of anybody.

Jaynie59 on May 18, 2009 at 3:41 PM

truly a powerfull speaker. The one thing I never hear anything about is the father of the unborn baby. Do they not matter at all? Are we to assume they are all irresponsible, low life, abandoners? Why is it only up to the mother to decide life or death? If the father wants to raise the child, should he have veto power over the abortion? In my opinion, abortion is the vilest of murder in that it is preventable. No liberal argument can change that, no one is punished with a child.

aceinstall on May 18, 2009 at 3:43 PM

That video is a great example of why thinking people think religious people are nuts.

People like that are enough to scare the crap out of anybody.

Jaynie59 on May 18, 2009 at 3:41 PM

Thinking people…Bias much? Nope too blinded by your hatred.

daesleeper on May 18, 2009 at 3:44 PM

Check out Piper’s “Make War” rant

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wrY0h33coR4

awesome

jp on May 18, 2009 at 3:44 PM

That video is a great example of why thinking people think religious people are nuts.

People like that are enough to scare the crap out of anybody.

Jaynie59 on May 18, 2009 at 3:41 PM

And there it is.

- The Cat

MirCat on May 18, 2009 at 3:44 PM

Doctors should lose their license to practice medicine for doing abortion.

Black Adam on May 18, 2009 at 3:58 PM

That video is a great example of why thinking people think religious people are nuts.

People like that are enough to scare the crap out of anybody.

Jaynie59 on May 18, 2009 at 3:41 PM

You are atrociously ignorant in your lack of disciplined education; that you fear logic is your own bane.

maverick muse on May 18, 2009 at 4:02 PM

And there it is.

- The Cat

MirCat on May 18, 2009 at 3:44 PM

Yes. But bearing witness to the truth is the responsibility of all who are called to know it.

maverick muse on May 18, 2009 at 4:04 PM

Um…aren’t adults also “clumps of cells” or does our matter change after birth?

thecountofincognito on May 18, 2009 at 3:34 PM

LOL

maverick muse on May 18, 2009 at 4:05 PM

It has been my experience that most religious people ARE thinking people and a great many irreligious people are not thinking people, but are simply sheeple who follow the popular fashion of the day, fearful of standing apart from the crowd.

single stack on May 18, 2009 at 4:06 PM

That video is a great example of why thinking people think religious people are nuts.

People like that are enough to scare the crap out of anybody.

Jaynie59 on May 18, 2009 at 3:41 PM

It’s the message that scares you the most. God’s Word.. showing your heart and soul how empty and lacking you are. The good part is that you don’t have to stay that way.

GoodBoy on May 18, 2009 at 4:16 PM

That video is a great example of why thinking people think religious people are nuts.

People like that are enough to scare the crap out of anybody.

Jaynie59 on May 18, 2009 at 3:41 PM

Blind ignorance on display.

If you think that John Piper isn’t a “thinking person”, I challenge you to read any one of his books. Maybe start with, “The Pleasures of God.” Listening to his preaching is often like drinking from a firehose. I’ve long held the opinion that if you attend his church for two years you should get a diploma in systematic theology and exegetics.

skydaddy on May 18, 2009 at 4:20 PM

People like that are enough to scare the crap out of anybody.

What scares you about them? Is it the fact that they point out if we keep “private family matters, private”, you might just decide to off Grandpa Joe? What’s the difference between Grandpa Joe and Baby Suzy?

katablog.com on May 18, 2009 at 4:30 PM

Um…aren’t adults also “clumps of cells” or does our matter change after birth?

thecountofincognito on May 18, 2009 at 3:34 PM

Yea, all the same. A wart, a fetus, an elephant, an army – all just clumps of cells. Sheese!
.
Frankly, if people believe there is a fully enfranchised human at conception then they are immoral for not spending all their energy including armed violence to stop all abortions.
.
I think that despite the rhetoric, people do not believe this in their heart. If millions of 5 year-olds were being slaughtered by doctors at the request of their mothers, people would stop it immediately by any means needed, but we do know there is a difference, don’t we? That’s why we just argue about it and not kill each other over of it.

bagoh20 on May 18, 2009 at 4:34 PM

It’s the message that scares you the most. God’s Word.. showing your heart and soul how empty and lacking you are. The good part is that you don’t have to stay that way.

GoodBoy on May 18, 2009 at 4:16 PM

I agree basically with the message but the delivery gives me the heebie jeebies. So maybe convincing people will take a different approach.

Do I really think this person “wept” for joy at Obama’s election? No. So that invalidates everything he says.

The guy might have teared up… got a lump in his throat… but “wept”?

Don’t you understand why the teary voice… is creepy. I mean the first or second time he thought of the numbers he probably felt some real emotion but after he has said it a thousand times he has to manufacture the emotion–it shows. It hurts his credibility to pretend.

petunia on May 18, 2009 at 4:49 PM

Here’s an excellent article from a few years ago, the claim of which is supported by the Gallup poll last week.

Matushka on May 18, 2009 at 4:53 PM

If you are “Pro-Choice”………….

………. open “Google”, under “Preferences” choose “Do not filter my search results”.

Then select “Images”, then type in “abortion pictures”……

……… enjoy the “choices” that were made.

Seven Percent Solution on May 18, 2009 at 4:53 PM

I have two reactions and a question about Pres. Obama’s talk at Notre Dame, and his speech about respect for opposing points of view.

The first has been well canvassed, that is, the impossibility of keeping an open mind about what is, essentially homicide.I cannot keep an open mind to those who want a Holocaust, be it Ahmedinejad of the Pro “Choice” lobby.

Secondly, the “respect for differing viewpoints” comment is a lie. Pres. Obama and his supporters do NOT respect those with opposing views. Apart from their efforts to prevent those with contrary opinions out of positions of authority (e.g. USSC), they also want to force those who oppose abortion to particiapte in it. they wish to force Doctors and Nurses who oppose abortion to perform them, and Catholic hospitals to provide them onsite. I suppose THIS is the point at which I could not accept the President speaking at Notre Dame.

My question, which is inspired by Mark Steyn’s/AP’s point on the difference between Pres. Obama and Ms. Prejean’s views on gay marriage (i.e. Ms. Prejean actually believes her position) is this. Do you think that the intellectuals at the top of Notre Dame’s administration actually believe Church teaching on abortion or is it, for them, an unfashionable anachronism?

Blaise on May 18, 2009 at 5:07 PM

and the real americans said……….. amen

workingforpigs on May 18, 2009 at 5:12 PM

Holy cow… that is effective.

AbaddonsReign on May 18, 2009 at 5:18 PM

re phrase

Consider this an especially vivid illustration of the point I made yesterday about the impossibility of “open-mindedness” about abortion mass murder when one’s religious conviction runs this deeply

That is the problem

One man’s mass murder is another man’s chiropractic adjustment

The video was rough. The words are powerful. It is hard for someone like me who believes letting born alive babies die alone in a closet without food or water is infanticide, to accept Rev Jenkins of Notre Dame speaking lightly of a man who finds closet snuffing of babies to be a highly personal matter that we can agree to disagree on

All anyone has to do is mention a baby being kept in a back room without sustenance or human touch and I want to grab a pitchfork

Anti abortion dialogue changed my heart a long time ago. I was a blob supporter until I began to believe in a soul, and the equal protection of unawakened humans

I am touched by ASPCA ads to rescue abused and abandoned animals. Another good cause. Neither puppies not babies deserve death.

Death is one of those hard issues that do not allow half way compromises

entagor on May 18, 2009 at 5:19 PM

That video is a great example of why thinking people think religious people are nuts.

People like that are enough to scare the crap out of anybody.

Jaynie59 on May 18, 2009 at 3:41 PM

Well, let’s hope it did “scare the crap” out of you! And while you’re at it, hopefully some good “crap” took its place.

journeyman on May 18, 2009 at 6:10 PM

I get irritaed when some deend abortion about it being the womans body and I have no right to tell them what to do otherwise. It’s not the woman getting the abortion whose heart is being stopped now is it?

Obama is beyond “Pro-Choice”., his record and rhetoric show him to be straight up Pro-Abortion. Anyone who voted for him who is Pro-Life betrayed the very principals and values that they claim to cherish. Those people are living a lie. Shame on them.

Yakko77 on May 18, 2009 at 6:41 PM

Piper is the real deal. I suspect that the “wept for joy at your inauguration” reference refers to the issue of race. I have heard him speak so many times on the issues of racism and abortion. As one who grew up in the deep south, racism has touched Piper in a personal way. When and his wife adopted a little African American girl their hearts became even more tied to these issues. Take a cursory breeze through his site and you will see that his emotion is sincere – not that he needs anyone to defend him. There are many many who are deeply impacted by this issue as this is an issue that potentially touches the whole person. I would be vary careful not to jump to a quick conclusion and write him off. Watch this video and you will see he does not fit your stereotype (seriously, watch the video).

doctor horton on May 18, 2009 at 6:42 PM

doctor horton on May 18, 2009 at 6:42 PM

The tolerant and faithful life he lives still wont stop some from calling him a racist for opposing The One I’m afraid.

Yakko77 on May 18, 2009 at 6:48 PM

I agree with the underlying message in the video sans the religious element. As an ethical question there is no doubt that a fetus is alive and that it has the same genetic structure as a human being. Therefore it is a human life. If left to grow it becomes like me or any other human being. I’m all about personal responsibility and, except in cases of rape, incest, or direct threat to the health of the mother, I believe abortion is an unjustifiable taking of a human life and an immoral act(Rape, incest etc are not exceptions I take lightly and I base them in part on aspects of personal responsibility).

I’m not entirely comfortable with the criminalization of abortion, but I do consider it an immoral act and judge those who participate in it(except in the cases of rape, incest, or direct threat to the health of the mother) like I would judge anyone who robs an innocent human life of its future. Through abortion a developing human being is robbed of their one goal, which is to be brought into this world and given the same chance each of us was given.

I’m not religious and I don’t believe in the supernatural, but I am in awe of human beings and believe in treating innocent human life with dignity no matter its form.

Stickeehands on May 18, 2009 at 6:49 PM

Nico was referring to 0bama, not Piper.

CDeb on May 18, 2009 at 2:25 PM

My apologies Nico. I misunderstood your comment.

shick on May 18, 2009 at 2:31 PM

Not a problem. No apologies necessary.

nico on May 18, 2009 at 7:17 PM

It’s the ’40’s in Nazi Germany. The Nazis just want to have a “dialog” about killing Jews.

It’s the new millennium and the Democrats want a “dialog” about killing children.

There’s nothing new under the sun.

Mojave Mark on May 18, 2009 at 7:27 PM

That video is a great example of why thinking people think religious people are nuts.

People like that are enough to scare the crap out of anybody.

Jaynie59 on May 18, 2009 at 3:41 PM

Jaynie..you and other leftist people are not “thinking people”.
To say that you are, would mean that you are actually…THINKING.
When you think, you are weighing the facts. Not throwing them out the window as mere opinion or ones own ‘choice’.

Leftists are and never have been thinkers. What it comes down do is ones own wants. Ones own selfish wants. That’s it.
To be Leftist means to basically be a hater of facts, and be a hater of (most of all) STANDARDS.
They hate anything and anyone that says that standards actually matter. Which is why we see the want to have abortion on demand, a bringdown of American education, a dismantling of the American economy, the distribution of wealth, the paying from achievers to pay off the debts of non-achievers, felons and the lazy.
The list is endless.
I am a conservative, because they still believe in standards. The problem has been that they don’t have the back bone in leadership to FIGHT for them.

Let us begin now.

Handel on May 18, 2009 at 7:28 PM

By that guys logic then the aborted fetuses live on infinitely. So no harm , no foul.

Don’t get me wrong I abhor Obamugabe and I’m a semi-anti-abortionist. (they should be mandatory for Libs)

TheSitRep on May 18, 2009 at 7:52 PM

Don’t you understand why the teary voice… is creepy. I mean the first or second time he thought of the numbers he probably felt some real emotion but after he has said it a thousand times he has to manufacture the emotion–it shows. It hurts his credibility to pretend.

petunia on May 18, 2009 at 4:49 PM

It hurts your humanity to admit to callous numbness. Some horrors, such as abortion, are easier to ignore when we do not regularly confront the facts. But if you reacquaint yourself with those facts regularly, maybe even surprisingly, then, if you have a conscience remaining, you can not help but be cut to the quick each time. Go to http://www.abortionno.org every day for a week, and tell me it has grown old and beneath your level of interest. Piper has an advantage over you. He seems to spend a great deal of time on the Holiness of God. He does so systematically and in fresh and insightful ways. I submit, a man so moved is more sensitive to all kinds of sin. Such a man begins to take on the character of the God he studies. And that God can not help but be emotionally involved.

It is convenient when one side can act conciliatory while their position remains the law, and effectively demand by their act that you concede your position ‘in fairness’ to their fake willingness to dialog. They would not feel quite the same were the shoe on the other foot.

AnotherOpinion on May 18, 2009 at 7:56 PM

By that guys logic then the aborted fetuses live on infinitely. So no harm , no foul.

TheSitRep on May 18, 2009 at 7:52 PM

Wow.

just….

Wow.

nico on May 18, 2009 at 8:02 PM

Most of John Piper’s sermons (including the January 25, 2009 sermon that the video was excerpted from) are freely available (as audio and text) on-line:

http://www.desiringgod.org/ResourceLibrary/Sermons/ByDate/

“So faith comes from hearing, and hearing by the word of Christ.” Romans 10:17

dtestard on May 18, 2009 at 8:45 PM

You either kill “it” or let “it” live. So make a choice, kill it or let it live. This isn’t a debate. You walk into the room, act or don’t act, and leave. No ‘overs’. No ‘ooopseys’. You either killed it, or you didn’t.

Limerick on May 18, 2009 at 9:17 PM

You’re right, Limerick. With something that is so “final,” why do NARAL and Planned Parenthood fight every effort to reduce the numbers of abortions, whether that’s a 48-hour wait, or the availability of an ultrasound or providing information about other options, such as adoption? I’ve never been able to understand all that resistance. And, why does PP overlook the state laws requiring parental notification when a minor is in their clinic, or reporting a likely statutory rape? Clearly they’re more interested in collecting the fee than they are in following the law.

LindaDinNev on May 18, 2009 at 9:33 PM

Who rejoiced at Obooba’s election except those who A.) favor chopping up unborn babies, or B.) were ignorant that Obooba was our most enthusiastic baby-chopping enabler to date?

Akzed on May 18, 2009 at 9:44 PM

Indeed. The most important thing [for left-liberals] — the supreme virtue — is “dialogue.”

The Americans’ left-liberals ape* the philosophers, for whom I think it may be that dialogue of a sort really is the supreme virtue. But the philosophers don’t carry on their dialogue openly in public. They’ve had that dialogue, and they seem to have come away largely persuaded–as much as philosophers can be persuaded–that open, philosophic dialogue would be catastrophic for all involved.

One of the errors of left-liberals is that they’ve learned a corrupt version of the “Enlightenment” philosophers’ public teachings about the importance of public teachings. With even my lowly interpretive ability, I have seen that the modern philosophers, including Machiavelli and those after him, are lying when they seem to praise total “candor,” “honesty,” and “authenticity.” They seem really to think that their never-ending dialogue about the unsolved problems of interest to them is not open to the public for limitless participation. They must remain in dialogue, but their dialogue must be shielded from the public, and the public from their dialogue.

—————
*I do mean to say that the left-liberals, including the President of the United States, are talking apes in comparison to the philosophers. Let them all feel the pathos of distance.

Kralizec on May 18, 2009 at 9:46 PM

Dear goopers, you still don’t get it. Americans don’t agree with anything you say anymore. You are the outcasts. The pariah’s. Thats why you continue to get pounded in elections. You’ve turned into whiny little babies. All you do is complain and pout. You think by getting angrier people will listen to you. Dude, Americans have stopped listening to rants.You get crazier every day.You lost most of the country when you agreed with Rush, when he said he wants Obama to fail. Gameover.Checkmate. Credibility gone. You became the party of hate, plain and simple. And yet you become more shrill, like doubling down will make everything alright. Your party is a joke, your chairman is a joke.Palin is a joke. Joe the plumber is a joke. But keep getting your hate on, its working so well for you.

athensboy on May 18, 2009 at 9:59 PM

From the moment an ovary frees an ovum, that ovum is on its own. Though it is within a woman, it is no longer part of the woman. Once fertilized – now called a zygote – it is still on its own. It must attach itself to the wall of the woman’s womb. There is no apparatus within the womb that finds, grabs hold of, and implants that zygote to the womb wall.

As the zygote develops into an embryo, the embryo develops the implantation (umbilical cord, placenta, etc.) that the embryo will use to tap nourishment from the woman. The woman doesn’t give the nourishment, the embryo takes it on its own.

Embryos can be developed outside the human body and kept for many years and viably implanted in a woman, and not necessarily the woman who shed the ovum in the first place. These embryos can be developed longer and longer outside the womb, and babies can be born more and more prematurely and live thanks to modern medicine. That means less dependence upon a womb, and more proof of the independence of the zygote/embryo/fetus.

Bottom line; once fertilized, that ovum becomes a separate living being, all on its own, dependent only upon its mother for the nourishment it takes.

It has more control over the mother than the mother has over it. The embryo secrets a chemical signal that halts the woman’s menstrual cycle and prevents the woman’s biological functions from expelling it. If the embryo dies, the “signal” stops, and the embryo is ejected(miscarriage).

No matter how you look at it, when you look at it, or what you call it, it is a separate living being – a separate HUMAN being, made at the moment of conception, AFTER it has been set free from its mother’s ovary, AFTER the sperm has been ejaculated from the father.

There is no other way to define abortion than to call it by what it does. It unjustifiably kills the zygote/embryo/fetus. It’s murder. It’s not a mass of protoplasm, it’s a separate living being. It’s not a part of its mother.

The mother has no right to destroy it. No one does. It’s the culmination of the joining of expelled objects from two people. No right exists that two(or more) people share. All rights are individual. This new human being has the right to life. Before conception, the woman may do with the ovum as she pleases. Before conception, the man may do with his sperm as he pleases. After conception, though, all right to that new living being belongs to that new living being.

As simple as this all sounds, and as simply as I have presented it, its incontrovertible. Abortion is murder. It’s the taking of life without due process. It’s assigning guilt for some ethereal crime by the new being so terrible that the ultimate penalty – death – must be proscribed.

Go forth and abort no more.

Woody

woodcdi on May 18, 2009 at 10:02 PM

Here I stand.
Defiant.
Apparently thinking people are automatically excluded from religious people.
Wow
Truly, ignorance is bliss. Thank you.
I really like the company over here. :-D

Blacksmith8 on May 18, 2009 at 10:07 PM

Excuse me did I hear an underdeveloped, grecian wind.
No?
Oh, nevermind. Spicey food always gives me gas.

Blacksmith8 on May 18, 2009 at 10:10 PM

athensboy on May 18, 2009 at 9:59 PM

That’s some funny sh^% right there. My irony meter just exploded.

DWB on May 18, 2009 at 10:11 PM

Athensboy kinda stinks at being a troll… he just makes people laugh because he makes no sense.

That’s some funny sh^% right there. My irony meter just exploded.

DWB on May 18, 2009 at 10:11 PM

Yeah.. OUR anger is out of control.. LOL!

GoodBoy on May 18, 2009 at 10:24 PM

athensboy on May 18, 2009 at 9:59 PM

How many babies do you want to kill?

Johan Klaus on May 18, 2009 at 10:24 PM

athensboy on May 18, 2009 at 9:59 PM

Someone left the door open or forgot to set the varmint traps.

Attention everyone, please. Do your best to ignore the spoiled, rotten little … thing/child in the room. It suffers from a sever personality disorder not unlike tourettes syndrome that compels it spit out foul taunts and meaningless rants in order to draw attention to it’s pitiful self. I understand that it writes like, sounds like, and looks like Gollum but it poses no threat and deserves no response or attention whatsoever. Just go about your business whilst I call pest control.

Allah? Ed? Anyone home? There’s a foul stench in the room.

Rod on May 18, 2009 at 10:25 PM

I think the analogy to slavery is appropriate….

Starlink on May 18, 2009 at 1:43 PM

So do I.

Red State State of Mind on May 18, 2009 at 11:00 PM

Dear goopers, you still don’t get it. Americans don’t agree with anything you say anymore.

51 % pro life in latest polling…?

You are the outcasts. The pariah’s. Thats why you continue to get pounded in elections. You’ve turned into whiny little babies. All you do is complain and pout. You think by getting angrier people will listen to you.

A 4 year election cycle doesn’t worry me, when folks like you are spokepeople for the radical Left.

Dude, Americans have stopped listening to rants.You get crazier every day.You lost most of the country when you agreed with Rush, when he said he wants Obama to fail. Gameover.Checkmate. Credibility gone. You became the party of hate, plain and simple.

What party does the ever so tolerant Perez Hilton belong to? Or those folks who knocked over the elderly woman carrying a cross? Projecting much?

And yet you become more shrill, like doubling down will make everything alright. Your party is a joke, your chairman is a joke.Palin is a joke. Joe the plumber is a joke. But keep getting your hate on, its working so well for you.

athensboy on May 18, 2009 at 9:59 PM

See you in 2010 “boy”

Red State State of Mind on May 18, 2009 at 11:04 PM

Athens Boy never answers and its part of his HATE that he accuses of us having? Hey Athens I don’t care how many elections we lose because those who are pro life won’t give up our convictions just to simply win elections. You and your ilk are enjoying your rewards now but later after this life you will have to answer the Great Judge on what you did with your life.

garydt on May 18, 2009 at 11:20 PM

Remember they have to count the parts. Two arms and two legs, a head and a torso. They count the parts to be sure they have the whole fetus.

bloggless on May 18, 2009 at 11:27 PM

If millions of 5 year-olds were being slaughtered by doctors at the request of their mothers, people would stop it immediately by any means needed, but we do know there is a difference, don’t we? That’s why we just argue about it and not kill each other over of it.

bagoh20 on May 18, 2009 at 4:34 PM

What about the people who are willing to do whatever it takes to stop the slaughter? Do you support them, or just call them extremists?

So I’d say your argument is more than a little hypocritical.

How much of the difference between the killing of 5-year olds and the killing of the unborn due to the simple fact that the unborn are not visible? Out of sight, out of mind, as it were.

I’d say your argument is wrong-headed on that basis alone.

And why do you only speak of babies not being human at the point of conception? Isn’t abortion permitted right up until the day of birth, when there’s no real question of viability?

In short, your argument, even at its best, is beside the point. The issue is not whether to permit the abortion of zygotes. The issue is that abortion is permitted up until the very moment of birth.

When will you concede that the current policy of permitting abortion up to the last minute is clearly wrong?

ThereGoesTheNeighborhood on May 18, 2009 at 11:41 PM

Thank you, Mr. Allahpundit, for sharing this video for the wider Hot Air audience.

I have benefitted from John Piper’s messages, especially his book, Sex and the Supremacy of Christ.

Thank you, AP

ColtsFan on May 18, 2009 at 11:45 PM

Not another mess for me….

Rod:

Attention everyone, please. Do your best to ignore the spoiled, rotten little … thing/child in the room.

Sorry, but no dice. In my experience, you don’t kill a troll by starvation, you kill it by OVERFEEDING.

And that is what I intend to do.

but it poses no threat and deserves no response or attention whatsoever.

True, but its claims and its insults DO, lest they go unchallenged and undefeated.

Just go about your business whilst I call pest control.

Ah, but what if my business IS to be pest control?

Now that that is out of the way…

athensboy:

Before I start, I am still waiting for those response.

Dear goopers, you still don’t get it. Americans don’t agree with anything you say anymore.

And this has changed how? Americans have always been divided, and we have always been the targets of choice when we are out of power. And this represents what sort of dramatic change from the norm?

You are the outcasts. The pariah’s. Thats why you continue to get pounded in elections.

Obviously, cause/effect is screwed up for you. No, we are not losing the elections because we are pariahs and outcasts, we are pariahs and outcasts BECAUSE WE LOST THE ELECTIONS.

That being said, you are correct. And that is something we must work to change in the coming days, weeks, months, and years.

You’ve turned into whiny little babies.

In some cases, yes, but you are also projecting.

All you do is complain and pout.

In many cases, that is sadly true.

You think by getting angrier people will listen to you.

All depends on HOW we channel that anger.

Dude, Americans have stopped listening to rants.

And would this explain your dismal preformance on these boards?

You get crazier every day.

Define Crazy.

You lost most of the country when you agreed with Rush, when he said he wants Obama to fail.

A. Proof?

B. Obviously, you cannot differentiate between Obama’s policies and Obama himself, which even Rush took the time to mention AT THE TIME>

C. When are you going to read a transcript?

Gameover.Checkmate. Credibility gone.

Oh, like how it was “Gameover” and “Checkmate” for Clinton after Lewinsky?

You became the party of hate, plain and simple.

This coming from the advocate for Jihadists who has made lewd and idiotic comments and insults to a wide range of people, ethnicities, and creeds?

And yet you become more shrill, like doubling down will make everything alright.

Well, it worked for the DNC in 2006 and 2008.

Your party is a joke

True, but if efficiency truly depended on what partisan hack “comedians” used as punchlines, Truman, Washington, FDR, and Reagan would have all been failures. Nice try, please roll again.

, your chairman is a joke.

True.

Palin is a joke. Joe the plumber is a joke.

And so is your President, your Congress, you oh-so grand reforms, you allies, you foreign policy, and your knavish trust in our foes.

At least Palin, Joe, and the party can be effective under the withering scrutiny of YOUR Media, while you operate almost entirely unopposed and still trip over your feet.

But keep getting your hate on, its working so well for you.

Given the tea parties, the rallies, and the gun purchases, I would say it is.

But all depends on HOW we channel our anger.

Any other questions, knave?

Also, to the fool who drew up this ad:

I wish I could be gentler or less critical, but I can not.

The bottom line is that you made your choice, and now you are dealing with it.

You had the choice to hold your nose and vote for McCain like the rest of we beleaguered NeoCons, but you chose to adopt the whimsy-and-sparkle candidate as your own.

Bluntly, you had EVERY oppertunity to find out what Obama stood for. Legions of bloggers and true journalists spent thousands of manhours gathering data from the far reaches of the world. It took time to weed out the kooks, but the fact is that by a couple weeks away from the election, all the evidence, all the data, all the proof about who Obama was, who his allies were, and what he stood for were lying only a click away for your scrutiny.

But never once did you look.

Instead, you chose to believe in Obama, in spite of all the data, all the evidence, and all the people shouting abreast of you to stop and look at what you were doing.

And now, you are finding out that the mask is off revealed EXACTLY WHAT THE EVIDENCE LYING IN FRONT OF YOUR FACES THE ENTIRE TIME SAID!

In the meantime, the Jihad grows in strength and in boldness around the world, the Chinese are seeking to dominate the Pacific, and Russia has grown even bolder, unrestrained save for the Bush-era tripwire, which graciously remains in place.

Hundreds Millions of lives, hundreds of millions of real, out-of-the-womb lives are at stake here.

That it took the abortion issue to raise your ire, to force you to confront the man who has shown the foreign policy ineptitudeness of Ike in his two terms in his few dozen days in office reveals how short-sighted you are.

And now you are crying and yelling about it, about what we have been trying to tell you all along.

And now, we are all dangling on the slim hopes that our foes do not utilize the oppertunities they have to the fullest, that our allies and soldiers can stem the tide long enough to save the West itself, that Obama can learn to become an American president worthy of th eoffice.

And much of that, we owe to you.

And we will not forget it.

We may forgive you, but it will be long and hard, and only redeemable after a long travel through the wilderness to reaffirm both the party and your dedication to the faith you preach.

If you wish to go even further into Obama’s camp, you are welcome to do so. Unlike the Left, we do not have “plantations” keeping you bound under pain of disenfranchisement, of isolation, or of financial or personal ruin.

But we may judge as we please, and we shall judge you harshly.

And now the only way for you is to make a walk to Canossa in penitence for your failures.

Is this harsh? Yes.

But not unjustly so.

After all,

WE TOLD YOU SO, WE TOLD YOU SO, WE TOLD YOU SO!

Turtler on May 18, 2009 at 11:48 PM

Most Americans are pro-life. Millions of women are pro-life. And all fetuses are pro-life. What is AnusBoy talkin about?

Geochelone on May 19, 2009 at 12:54 AM

This guy is really good. The animation is perfect as well. :) :) :)

Theophile on May 19, 2009 at 5:05 AM

That video is a great example of why thinking people think religious people are nuts.

Your words are a great example of how deluded people console themselves with the cold comfort of false Reason.

People like that are enough to scare the crap out of anybody.

That is the point. You are full of crap. Jesus is a soul washer.

rhodeymark on May 19, 2009 at 6:38 AM

That video is a great example of why thinking people think religious people are nuts.
People like that are enough to scare the crap out of anybody.
Jaynie59 on May 18, 2009 at 3:41 PM

Alas, if only we could all be as smart as you.

Think about this: it’s not only religious people who believe that life begins at conception. It’s not only religious people who believe that a woman does not have carte blanche to destroy the life inside her at her convenience.

CarolynM on May 19, 2009 at 6:59 AM

Well done, and thank you for posting this AllahPundit.
.

This is the lie, the deceit which is consuming America. It has poisoned our politics, our governance and our culture. Our culture, law and constitution are founded upon the right to life as they are founded upon the right to liberty. Slavery required no small deceit regarding the personhood, the “full humaness” of Black slaves. It also required many small deceits and compromises of empathy. Abortion requires no small deceit regarding the personhood, the “full humaness” of unborn children. It also requires many small deceits and compromises of empathy, prudence and self-restraint. But Natural Law tells us, I believe, that substantially all of us know that abortion kills children. That reality is now all to obvious … so we must, each of us, tell ourselves enabling deceits, lest our empathy and conscience be awakened.
.

Our killing of children via abortion is at one with the raging character assassination and politics of personal destruction, the scapegoating which now fill our public square. They both require no small deceit and an effacement of the “humaness” of the victim … They are both a return to the “old religion”…

Mike OMalley on May 19, 2009 at 7:06 AM

This guy’s god answered his prayers in giving him Obama. Now Obama will give carbon credits for each CO2 generator not delivered. The only way abortion would be made illegal is the coming of shari’a law to the U.S. If current trends continue this will happen in Europe in 50 to 70 years and the US may follow in another 30. The reason is, of course, demographics. Muslim women in Europe are producing, on average, 5.5 children whereas native European women are regular clients at the abortion mills. The process is slower in the US mainly because of the Mexican Catholic immigration (they still follow the teachings of the church). But this will change as the children are assimilated into the culture. Watch for an influx of refugees from Islamic countries who will come and eventually bring in their extended families. They will not assimilate and it will be Europe redux.

Annar on May 19, 2009 at 7:24 AM

“Mr. President – Some of us wept for joy at your inaugeration…”

People who are pro-Life who wept for joy at the inaugeration of President Obama were ignorant to an extent that I have a hard time understanding. We all knew his position, and his position has not changed.

Nor will it change.

gridlock2 on May 19, 2009 at 7:29 AM

Nor will it change.

gridlock2 on May 19, 2009 at 7:29 AM

There will only be the deception and perception of change.

shick on May 19, 2009 at 7:33 AM

I find myself, though somewhat of a limited early-term pro-choicer, being polarized by Obama’s distinctly unserious treatment of the issue. His rhetorical sleight of hand would marginalize the issue Piper raises in favor of some kind of feel-good dialogue, and I resent it.

petefrt on May 19, 2009 at 7:56 AM

Quit giving to the Catholic church… Watch how fast they become clear on where they stand.

lexa on May 19, 2009 at 8:18 AM

WE TOLD YOU SO, WE TOLD YOU SO, WE TOLD YOU SO!

Turtler on May 18, 2009 at 11:48 PM

While I appreciate and understand your passion and agree wholeheartedly with all you’ve written, I’m not sure you understand that, with athensboy, you’re responding to a robot. It’s like arguing with a candy machine that spits out a Snickers when you paid for a Mars Bar. At best, you are wasting your time and at worst, allowing him to, yet again, hijack another thread. (Which, being the class A hypocrite I am, I’m contributing to.)

My comments are specific to athensboy who has proven to have neither the desire nor the intellect to debate anyone. His posts are limited to name calling which he cuts and pastes from his limited archive of liberal banality for one reason: to draw attention to himself so as to feed his screwed up ego. Like any pest, feeding him keeps him coming back for more. Leave him be. He will slink away.

If your heart is to defend the faith against those that would attack it, then I would suggest you choose a worthy opponent within a venue that’s topic-relevant and related and do battle there. I would enjoy reading that, your time would be well-spent, and you might actually help lead some poor liberal fool out of the darkness.

Rod on May 19, 2009 at 8:24 AM

But keep getting your hate on, its working so well for you.

athensboy on May 18, 2009 at 9:59 PM

Back at you, jackass.

DrSteve on May 19, 2009 at 8:27 AM

I never advocated abortion, would never have had one and would have done my best to encourage a friend or family member to rethink the decision and offer alternative options. Yet I was someone who leaned pro-choice, simply because I thought we should have the right to have the opportunity make that choice, I have since changed my mind. I evidently had my head buried (I would prefer to think in the sand, but I’m sure there are those who might think other locations!!) because in my naivety I assumed abortions were not available after the first trimester. OMG… when I found out that I was so wrong, I immediately changed my opinion. When I found out that babies were left to die after late term “abortions” that’s wrong on far too many levels – morally, ethically, legally? (I mean, come on, you go to jail for animal abuse) and broke my heart. How in the name of all that’s holy (or simply with compassion) can we allow this to happen? We need to have loud voices over the prohibition of this atrocity. We need to educate, educate and educate somemore. We need to strongly offer the Mother alternatives. And, I’m sure I’ll get slammed for this, but in light of all our tax dollars that go to crap, I”d rather pay someone a stipend to carry the baby to term and give it away for adoption than pay for her abortion.

BTW, a couple of days ago, I saw my granddaughter’s (due in Oct) ultrasound. The beauty of her tiny body brought tears to my eyes. Her little heartbeat, her rolls and stretches, watching her suck her thumb served as a reminder to me that millions of precious lives are being ripped from their mothers and left to die a cold, loveless death. This should never be allowed to happen.

By that guys logic then the aborted fetuses live on infinitely. So no harm , no foul.

TheSitRep on May 18, 2009 at 7:52 PM

Wow.

just….

Wow.

nico on May 18, 2009 at 8:02 PM

Nico – kind of leaves you speechless doesn’t it? To Thesitrep, no those tiny souls live on eternally in God’s embrace and yes, there is great harm and great foulness.

ladyhawke53 on May 19, 2009 at 9:12 AM

The video was just fantastic. Powerful words, strikingly presented.

To parallel these sentiments, victims of domestic violence often claim that the violence done to them is a family matter. From the point of conception these littlest people have a DNA all their own. These little beings are not a mass of cells, scab or hang nail. These little beings are as helpless as any child. If any of us have souls, these littlest beings have souls. A society is only great if it can protect the weak and defenseless. We don’t hate or judge anybody, we just wish President Obama would take time to reflect on the words he speaks.

Angry Dumbo on May 19, 2009 at 10:50 AM

I’m proud that John was my pastor for many years. He baptised me and my wife and officiated at our wedding.

skydaddy on May 18, 2009 at 3:40 PM

Couldn’t resist contrasting with the “pastor” who baptized and officiated for the Obamas.

SheofTwoMinds on May 19, 2009 at 11:49 AM

and nothing worth getting too upset about.

If not this, then is anything worth getting upset about? This is a foundational issue for our country. One side throws all morality into the crapper, and the other defends innocence.

kirkill on May 19, 2009 at 11:57 AM

Look….until the LIFE! warriors (including Benedict the Bad Shepherd) can accept that a differentiated cell clump is not “human life”, this argument goes no where.
First tri-abortions have to be free, legal, and easy.
Take a phreakin’ embryology course, stupid mouthbreathers.

You had had 8 years to overturn Roe.
It sure ain’t gonna happen now.

strangelet on May 18, 2009 at 2:09 PM

So your reason for declaring said “differentiated cell-clump” anything other than a human child would be … what? Will that clump ever be anything but a human child unless it dies?

You know what it is. You only play these puerile definition games because they give you comfort for a morally untenable position.

TheUnrepentantGeek on May 19, 2009 at 12:10 PM

differentiated cell-clump

You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means.

CDeb on May 19, 2009 at 12:15 PM

Another over the top, hysterical video which does nothing to reduce the number of terminations. Why don’t these people spend time promoting birth control education? Oh wait, they can’t. Sex is a no, no until your are married.

Chekote on May 19, 2009 at 12:33 PM

Awesome and powerful video.

jediwebdude on May 19, 2009 at 12:37 PM

Arguing about abortion is a waste of time, energy and resources. The opinions of a mere citizen have no chance of influencing anything. Even the opinions of politicians have no value. This issue is in the hands of the courts. Only the opinions of judges matter. No one in America – save judges – can have any impact on abortion.

American judges’ obsessive imposition of infanticide will eventually cause the destruction of the great American experiment. So sad.

lonesomecharlie on May 19, 2009 at 1:20 PM

I think the key is that mindsets & attitudes are slow to change; but they definitely can change. I have always been conservative but I was actually pro-choice some years ago. It was the easier stand to take which is usually true for liberal causes. I now can’t imagine being anything other than pro-life. I think the good news is people can change in the direction I did…but I can’t see many pro-life people changing to pro-death.

DCJeff on May 19, 2009 at 1:30 PM

Rod:

While I appreciate and understand your passion and agree wholeheartedly with all you’ve written,

Thank you.

It’s like arguing with a candy machine that spits out a Snickers when you paid for a Mars Bar. At best, you are wasting your time and at worst, allowing him to, yet again, hijack another thread. (Which, being the class A hypocrite I am, I’m contributing to.)

It’s like arguing with a candy machine that spits out a Snickers when you paid for a Mars Bar. At best, you are wasting your time and at worst, allowing him to, yet again, hijack another thread. (Which, being the class A hypocrite I am, I’m contributing to.)

I’m not sure you understand that, with athensboy, you’re responding to a robot.

A robot? I believe that comparison is an insult to robots. Whoever it is literally has no ability to argue rationally or to rise to the task. I know. The reference to “replies” refers to my previous rebuttals of him, where I am still waiting for a counter (which never comes). I know what he is like.

It’s like arguing with a candy machine that spits out a Snickers when you paid for a Mars Bar.

Nope, because at least then you have something tasty to eat (those allergic to peanuts nonwithstanding).

At best, you are wasting your time and at worst, allowing him to, yet again, hijack another thread. (Which, being the class A hypocrite I am, I’m contributing to.)

Actually, in my previous experience, the opposite is true. When somebody bothers to lay out the case in detail and persistently STAY on him and not let him do anything without nailing him, he tends to bolt. In addition, if nothing else, they at least deny him the ability to get the “final say.”

My comments are specific to athensboy who has proven to have neither the desire nor the intellect to debate anyone. His posts are limited to name calling which he cuts and pastes from his limited archive of liberal banality for one reason: to draw attention to himself so as to feed his screwed up ego.

True, and I know that well enough.

Like any pest, feeding him keeps him coming back for more. Leave him be. He will slink away.

I don’t believe so. He tends to stick on it and unless burned off, often will. Which is why I always tend to pound him in length and in detail to trigger his escape tendencies. He is an idiot, and one I don’t want to see, but my experiences have led me to believe that the best remedy is to respond with overwhelming force against him.

If your heart is to defend the faith against those that would attack it,

Ah, here’s another thing: I’m not seeking to “defend the faith,” persee, as I am just your normal, extremely cynical Diest, and my stance on abortion is that of critical ambivalence (I don’t like it, but I don’t see much that can cope with the issues at hand) at best. My main objective is to defend my values (which are most in common with Conservative principles than anything else, but are distinctly seperate on many occasions) as best as I can. And if that means laying the smackdown on Obama, athensboy, or extremely naive preachers with buyer’s angst, than I am perfectly willing to do so.

then I would suggest you choose a worthy opponent within a venue that’s topic-relevant and related and do battle there.

And I shall, and I often have. Indeed, I probably spend far more time doing that than I do moping up after the “drooling” trolls. But I believe that mopping up the “robots” is also necessary because failure to do so will condemn us by our silence and leave the field to them.

I would enjoy reading that, your time would be well-spent, and you might actually help lead some poor liberal fool out of the darkness.

All of which I hope to do, and am working on, and have been. However, somebody has to clean up after athensboy, and I volunteer.

And besides, we probably will not hear from him again for the duration of this thread, as I mentioned: he usually runs from my counters.

Turtler on May 19, 2009 at 3:11 PM

Although I believe that abortion is the willful and premeditated termination of human life (aka murder) I do not believe anything in the first 45 seconds of the video either. It is arrogant.

watson007 on May 19, 2009 at 3:22 PM

So the parade of idioticy continues unabated with yet another “robotic” troll:

strangelet:

I am still awaiting your responses.

Look….until the LIFE! warriors (including Benedict the Bad Shepherd) can accept that a differentiated cell clump is not “human life”, this argument goes no where.

Correction: until the LIFE! warriors can adaquately organize themselves and their views and both sides drop the outrageous and idiotic generalizations, this will go nowhere.

Also, how big does that “differentiated cell clump” have to be in order to be classified as sentient? How long along in its development cycle? How long after conception?

DO YOU REALIZE THAT YOU are a “Differentiated cell clump?”

First tri-abortions have to be free, legal, and easy.

Under what circumstances and with what level of parental consent? Should we make them so easy that one can literally FORCE a woman to have an abortion? Much depends on these parameters, fool, and while I am one of the more moderate and ambivalent individuals on this site in regards to abortion, even I am not foolish enough to not recognize the importance of these conditions.

Take a phreakin’ embryology course, stupid mouthbreathers.

I have, idiot. And I also have dealt with some births and abortions on a first-or-secondhand basis.

Have you?

And I am a mouthbreather. Indeed, I have it on my medical file and make no secret of it. I go to bed almost every night with a C-PAC to perserve my oxygen flow.

And I can still kick your sorry arse all over these forums.

And just because I am a mouthbreather does not mean the rest are, much less that they are “stupid.” Such generalizations merely shoot you in the foot.

You had had 8 years to overturn Roe.
It sure ain’t gonna happen now.

Remind me about “Separate but Equal.”

While I am moderately pro-Roe, I realize it could be overturned.

Turtler on May 19, 2009 at 3:31 PM

Nico – kind of leaves you speechless doesn’t it?

ladyhawke53 on May 19, 2009 at 9:12 AM

Ironically, Mr. Piper says people wept for joy at the Abortionist-in-Chief’s inauguration. I’ve wept for joy exactly once in my lifetime: when the doctor lifted my precious baby boy from his mother during her C-section.

nico on May 19, 2009 at 3:53 PM

Another over the top, hysterical video which does nothing to reduce the number of terminations. Why don’t these people spend time promoting birth control education? Oh wait, they can’t. Sex is a no, no until your are married.

Chekote on May 19, 2009 at 12:33 PM

LOL!

To what degree must American Public School education be dumbed down so that the general public can no longer appreciate the electrifying clarity of this very American idiom, peaching.
.
I have no doubt that Johnathan Edwards, Lincoln and Martin Luther King would much appreciate John Piper’s moving rhetoric.
.

In regard to the second part, promoting birth control is what got us into this mess. Before Wade vs. Roe the promotion of artificial birth control was sufficiently effective to decouple sex from marriage and to increase sexual promiscuity in American society. However, artificial birth control was and continues to be insufficiently reliable in the real world (as opposed to in the lab) to reduce the numbers of unwanted pregnancies. The reasons for this are probably instinctual. As a consequence the number to unwanted pregnancies significantly increased. Abortion is used as a backup because in practice artificial birth control has never worked to reduce the numbers of unwanted pregnancies in unmarried women. The pre-Sexual Revolution “sexual economy” which relied on absence and a reliable promise of marriage for a single women who became pregnant from sex outside of marriage.

.

Mike OMalley on May 19, 2009 at 10:19 PM

Another over the top, hysterical video which does nothing to reduce the number of terminations. Why don’t these people spend time promoting birth control education? Oh wait, they can’t. Sex is a no, no until your are married.

Chekote on May 19, 2009 at 12:33 PM

LOL!

To what degree must American Public School education be dumbed down so that the general public can no longer appreciate the electrifying clarity of this very American idiom, peaching.
.
I have no doubt that Johnathan Edwards, Lincoln and Martin Luther King would much appreciate John Piper’s moving rhetoric.
.

In regard to the second part, promoting birth control is what got us into this mess. Before Wade vs. Roe the promotion of artificial birth control was sufficiently effective to decouple sex from marriage and to increase sexual promiscuity in American society. However, artificial birth control was and continues to be insufficiently reliable in the real world (as opposed to in the lab) to reduce the numbers of unwanted pregnancies. The reasons for this are probably instinctual. As a consequence the number to unwanted pregnancies significantly increased. Abortion is used as a backup because in practice artificial birth control has never worked to reduce the numbers of unwanted pregnancies in unmarried women (beginning at the Sexual Revolution). The pre-Sexual Revolution “sexual economy”, which relied on absence and a reliable promise of marriage for a single women who became pregnant from sex outside of marriage, was far more effective a reducing illegitimacy than the post Sexual Revolution regime of artificial birth control and abortion combined.

Mike OMalley on May 19, 2009 at 10:28 PM

Thank you for posting this, Allah.

I mean that — sincerely.

sanantonian on May 20, 2009 at 12:03 AM

Although I believe that abortion is the willful and premeditated termination of human life (aka murder) I do not believe anything in the first 45 seconds of the video either. It is arrogant.

watson007 on May 19, 2009 at 3:22 PM

I am just glad you are pro-life. (No one says you have to be logically consistent!)

sanantonian on May 20, 2009 at 12:07 AM

I am a Christian.

I am Prolife.

And videos like this one drive me nuts. Because I hardly see abortion as a religious issue. Unless, that is, atheists and agnostics are now saying that believing that the taking human life is wrong, is a religious belief.

Yes, God did say “do not murder”- but is this not something that we can all agree on? That murder is wrong?

The fetus is a human.
The fetus is unique- of it’s own DNA.
The fetus is alive.
The fetus is innocent.

Therefore, abortion is the murder of a human being, and is wrong. Nothing religious about it.

Jewels on May 20, 2009 at 12:06 PM

Comment pages: 1 2 3


You must be logged in to post a comment.