Hot Air Mobile
Home The Vault Gear About
Hot Air -- get your fill


US removes Saddam’s yellowcake uranium — from first Gulf War

posted at 8:05 am on July 7, 2008 by Ed Morrissey
Share on Facebook | printer-friendly

Yesterday, the Associated Press reported that the US has secretly moved the yellowcake uranium held under seal since the first Gulf War from Iraq to a Canadian port, as part of a multi-million-dollar sale.  The Iraqis have long wanted it gone, and the removal keeps the radioactive material from terrorists — although it doesn’t have much value without a cascade of centrifuges to enrich it, other than a panic factor.  Even in the wake of dispatching the last of Saddam’s yellowcake, however, misinformation abounded.

First, let’s start with the AP itself.  Proving that it learned nothing over the last five years in terms of research, it gets the Joe Wilson story wrong — again:

Accusations that Saddam had tried to purchase more yellowcake from the African nation of Niger – and an article by a former U.S. ambassador refuting the claims – led to a wide-ranging probe into Washington leaks that reached high into the Bush administration.

Brian Murphy follows a long tradition of getting this story completely wrong at the AP.   Niger has four exports: uranium ore, livestock products, cowpeas, and onions.  Wilson reported that the Prime Minister had been approached by an Iraqi group interested in secret negotiations for an export deal, and the PM didn’t think that the Iraqis wanted to secretly buy onions.  Wilson reported back that Niger believed that the Iraqis had attempted to make a uranium purchase, but had refused their advances.  This came out years ago in an investigative report by the Senate Intelligence Committee, a report that the AP’s myriad of reporters still has managed to miss for three years.

Next, a slew of e-mails came yesterday which hailed this as proof that Saddam Hussein had a nuclear-weapons program.  It does prove that he had a nuclear program — before the first Gulf War.  For those of us who recall the issue of yellowcake in Iraq, this is the same stash that the IAEA had sealed during its inspections immediately after that war.  The seals remained on the compound, which means that Saddam never used it again.  In fact, that’s why we suspected him of attempting to purchase more from Niger, because he couldn’t get his hands on this yellowcake without triggering a new war.

This doesn’t have anything to do with continuing efforts by Saddam to produce nuclear weapons.  After the rejection by Niger, no one has produced any evidence that Saddam got fissile material from anywhere else, although evidence has arisen that he kept his nuclear technology on standby for reinstatement as soon as the sanctions got lifted.  He continued to work with chemical and possibly biological weapons for several years, according to captured IIS documents, but the nuclear progam appears to have been shut down effectively.

The real news is that the yellowcake has finally been removed from Iraq, along with the temptation to use it.  It now sits in the hands of the Canadians, who will put it to peaceful uses, removing one major security headache from the Maliki government and the US military.  We can now help clean up the Tuwaitha area and close another dark chapter from the Saddam Hussein era.


Blowback

Note from Hot Air management: This section is for comments from Hot Air's community of registered readers. Please don't assume that Hot Air management agrees with or otherwise endorses any particular comment just because we let it stand. A reminder: Anyone who fails to comply with our terms of use may lose their posting privilege.

Trackbacks/Pings

Trackback URL

Comments

Comment pages:

After being forced from its strongholds in the west and centre of Iraq in the past two years, Al-Qaeda’s dwindling band of fighters has made a defiant “last stand” in the northern city of Mosul. A huge operation to crush the 1,200 fighters who remained from a terrorist force once estimated at more than 12,000 began on May 10. Operation Lion’s Roar, in which the Iraqi army combined forces with the Americans’ 3rd Armoured Cavalry Regiment, has already resulted in the death of Abu Khalaf, the Al-Qaeda leader, and the capture of more than 1,000 suspects. . . .Major-General Mark Hertling, American commander in the north, said: “I think we’re at the irreversible point.”

It’s too bad, as Andy McCarthy notes, that you have to look to the foreign press to learn about this significant victory.

The pattern continues with every story coming out of Iraq. The American MSM continues their efforts to “shape” the news to fit a ultra Liberal agenda.

Keemo on July 7, 2008 at 8:17 AM

It does, however, demonstrate that Saddam’s wmd infrastructure and his intentions were dangerous, and not benign, peaceful, or ‘nothing to be concerned about.’ 550 tons of yellowcake is a lot of dangerous stuff. In his interrogations, and in the interrogations of his inner circle, everyone agreed he intended to restart his programs once sanctions more and more as sanctions eroded more and more. It is not out of the realm of possibility that the AQ Khan network or that Saddam’s regime could’ve negotiated with Libya to trade yellowcake for enriched uranium, and the IAEA would’ve allowed this as long as it was a declared transfer.

Remember as well that Tuwaitha is so contaminated that when US forces first arrived, they thought they found loose plutonium, and many had to be treated for exposure.

Lastly, how effective were those UN “tags” on the al Samoud and al Fatah rockets? As I recall, several were fired at Coalition HQ despite being tagged, and one almost hit the command center w Gen Franks and his staff.

Tags and padlocks were a joke. See also Kerry’s missing RDX from the election 04 October surprise. That RDX was “tagged” by the UN as well.

scottm on July 7, 2008 at 8:17 AM

Brian Murphy follows a long tradition of getting this story completely wrong at the AP.

Capt’n, when you WILLFULLY “get it wrong”, because you are a BDS-Afflicted, Anti-American/Pro-Jihadi Propaganda outlet, such as the AP is, that is not “getting it wrong”; that is deliberately, willfully, and pre-meditatedly proving aid and comfort to the enemy, and acting as a seditionist propaganda outlet.

These clowns make Tokyo Rose look like a Patriot!

Dale in Atlanta on July 7, 2008 at 8:21 AM

This doesn’t have anything to do with continuing efforts by Saddam to produce nuclear weapons.

Well, yes it does, actually. The yellowcake may have been left over from Gulf War I, but it was still in Iraq. We know from the final report of the Iraq Survey Group that Saddam had every intention of restarting his nuclear program once the sanctions regime had collapsed. Once that had happened, those seals would have come off in a split second.

You’re right that the AP reported this story badly (Are we surprised), but I’d argue that it was still relevant to the need to remove Saddam.

irishspy on July 7, 2008 at 8:38 AM

In an earlier time, Ed, I’d suspect you had an anonymous source in the cutting room floor department at AP.

Dusty on July 7, 2008 at 9:07 AM

This is an old story that has nothing to do with Wilson/Plame.

Wilson lied and the Democrats beat that dead horse for political advantage to the detriment of the nation.

However, we know exactly where this yellowcake came from, and the Niger portion (199.9 tons) was purchased in 1981. Really!

This is not relevant to the Wilson lies! Or the reason we went to war! This was declared! Didn’t involve Saddam under sanctions – period!

This yellow cake is not a new revelation or a new admission of Iraqi guilt. This is simply the fitting resolution of an old news story.

Simple as that.
David

LifeTrek on July 7, 2008 at 9:14 AM

Let me add, this was declared and under IAEA control, as a matter of fact in 2004 they threw a fit that we had disturbed the storage. I summarized the history of this yellowcake here (same post linked)
David

LifeTrek on July 7, 2008 at 9:18 AM

First to say “nukular.”

fossten on July 7, 2008 at 9:22 AM

It now sits in the hands of the Canadians, who will put it to peaceful uses

Greenpeace still thinks we’re evil, just for co-operating with Americans.

It was big news on TV here last night, and it was a business deal. The yellowcake was bought by a private company for “tens of millions” of dollars, and will likely be resold as reactor fuel. A tiny concern is that the facility in Saskatchewan where it will be stored apparently has a poor safety record.

Frozen Tex on July 7, 2008 at 9:37 AM

These clowns make Tokyo Rose look like a Patriot!

Dale in Atlanta on July 7, 2008 at 8:21 AM

Dale, it’s my turn to tell you a story. Tokyo Rose was an American girl of Japanese descent. She was in Japan visiting a sick aunt when the war broke out. The Japanese government refused to allow her to return to the US when other US citizens left Japan. With no way out and running out of food, she took a job as a typist. She ended up on the radio reading copy that she got from captured Americans. Once the war was over, she returned to her beloved America only to be tried as a war criminal and stripped of her citizenship but, oddly enough, allowed to remain. She worked in her family’s import/export shop in Chicago until her death in 2006.

I’d rather have a dozen Iva Toguris than even one AP “reporter.”

Kafir on July 7, 2008 at 9:37 AM

Kudos to the military for a successful operation in getting the material out of country and across the globe safely.

CP on July 7, 2008 at 9:43 AM

I’d rather have a dozen Iva Toguris than even one AP “reporter.”

Kafir on July 7, 2008 at 9:37 AM

Kafir: I confess, you jogged my memory; I remember seeing that 60min thing on Tokyo Rose now, but it must have been 30 years ago, at least!

Anyway, I used the caricature of Tokyo Rose, rather than the reality.

A better example would’ve been “Hanoi” Jane Fonda!

Dale in Atlanta on July 7, 2008 at 9:51 AM

No comment available from Joe Wilson or Valarie Plame.

trs on July 7, 2008 at 10:05 AM

Kafir:

I have to add that as high school student in the 1960’s I went into the shop just to see the famous Tokoyo Rose I kept hearing about in movies and reading in books. The shop was less then a mile from where I lived.

jerryofva on July 7, 2008 at 10:11 AM

CBC news today

The huge stockpile of concentrated natural uranium reached Montreal on Saturday in a top-secret journey that included a two-week airlift from Baghdad and a voyage across two oceans.

Facilities in Port Hope will refine more than 500 tonnes of “yellowcake” uranium — the seed material for higher-grade nuclear enrichment.

Monas on July 7, 2008 at 10:32 AM

Saddam couldn’t really get to it due to the IAEA sanctions and inspections.

But who do you think financed and supplied the 2600 tons that were turned over by Libya when they disclosed their program?

Twenty thousand Iraq people working there, AQ Kahn origin centrifuges and bomb plans all from Saddam to outsource the work.

Now if the market for yellow cake is so controlled, where did Libya get it, off the internet on Ebay?

CommentGuy on July 7, 2008 at 10:33 AM

Oh and since then Libya just disclosed another additional 1000 tons to France to work a power reactor deal.

That makes 3600 tons and counting.

CommentGuy on July 7, 2008 at 10:35 AM

It now sits in the hands of the Canadians, who will put it to peaceful uses,

Of course we will. Especially for our Danish friends. Bwahahaha. Er, I mean, of course.

Re. Frozen Tex: and what’s also funny about how our MSM is reporting this is that they (or the headline writers, at least) are making a big deal out of this being a “secret” deal and mission. Yeah, I wonder why anyone would want to have removed the yellowcake from Iraq in secret and not have front-page coverage of when the shipments were scheduled etc.? Gee, I wonder why?

Also, I hadn’t read about storing it in Saskatchewan, Frozen Tex: I assumed it was going to be used at the Bruce nuclear power plant as fuel seeing as they’re the ones who bought it.

andycanuck on July 7, 2008 at 11:03 AM

There are more points missing.

Yes, the IAEA did “put the seal on” 500 tons of yellowcake at Al—Tuwaitha. When our boys arrived, there was 488 tons of Yellowcake and 1.8 tons of enriched U stored separately.

Perhaps fairies broke in and put 22 tons of Yellowcake into the machinery (centrifuges) to make the 1.8 tons of enriched-U?

Allah, if you update this post, how bout showing your readers what an actual UN/IAEA “seal” looks like (and also note that the “seal” on one set of doors was undermined by the open air shafts and the other doors left open/unsealed/unmonitored (we even have film of trucks going into and out of the “sealed” bunker).

I’m just much more interested in how 22 tons under UN/IAEA seal turned into 1.8 tons of enriched-U.

Jason Coleman on July 7, 2008 at 11:12 AM

US removes Saddam’s yellowcake uranium — from first Gulf War

I hope Joe Wilson, and his dumber blond wife are reading this article. IMO, The whole thing came down ass backwards. Joe and his Pink Panther wife should have be doing time, and not Scooter Libbey.

byteshredder on July 7, 2008 at 12:03 PM

LifeTrek on July 7, 2008 at 9:18 AM

You state in your blog that “Some are reporting this as a new unreported finding.” Who are the “some” that you’re referring to?

RMCS_USN on July 7, 2008 at 2:51 PM

Ed,
As far as the AP goes, if Wilson’s going to write an op-ed for the Times that contradicts his own report to the CIA, I can’t necessarily blame the AP for jumping on it. They picked up on Wilson’s statement that “The next day, I reminded a friend at the State Department of my trip and suggested that if the president had been referring to Niger, then his conclusion was not borne out by the facts as I understood them.” Wilson left that door open. He had already stated that Iraq had attempted negotiations with Niger, now he states those weren’t the facts as he understood them? The AP can now use the line “…and an article by a former U.S. ambassador refuting the claims” because they can cite the op-ed as their source.
I can’t see any evidence of any wrongdoing by Valerie Plame either. So she suggested her husband for the trip, so what? No one was twisting the CIA’s arm to send him, were they?

RMCS_USN on July 7, 2008 at 3:59 PM

RMCS_USN on July 7, 2008 at 2:51 PM

The American Thinker right off the top of my head, they have updated since I posted. They had another on their blog that I can’t seem to access as it has moved off the front page.

Don Surber.

Patterico

And others I had noted that linked off these three.

Hope that helps.
David

LifeTrek on July 7, 2008 at 6:20 PM

While the left are having a fit,I’m pretty sure this
shipment is heading to Elloit Lake,Cameco Plant,around
60 miles were I’m located!

And thank-g!d,we don’t here a peep from the so-called
enviromental wacko’s,up here in the north!

After all peace groups aren’t for peace,their a political
activist organization!:)

canopfor on July 7, 2008 at 6:20 PM

ooops,thats around 60 miles from where I’m located!

canopfor on July 7, 2008 at 6:23 PM

For me the real point of the yellowcake news was the quantification of the amount.
I had already been aware that ’some’ yellowcake was in Saddam’s hands — but never understood it was 550 metric tons, over one million pounds of just-waiting-for-the-right-time-for-processing uranium ore.
I wonder what would happen if a private citizen had that size stockpile [locked up, of course] in their barn with a big blue ‘UN Do Not Enter’ sign/seal…
For peaceful investment purposes, you understand.

LaMonte on July 7, 2008 at 8:56 PM

LifeTrek on July 7, 2008 at 6:20 PM

They didn’t exactly say it was new yellowcake, but they left speculation open by NOT saying it was from BEFORE the first Gulf War.

RMCS_USN on July 7, 2008 at 10:02 PM

RMCS_USN — they were reporting it as news we hadn’t heard, not as newly discovered, that may not have been clear in that line from my post but in context I think it got that across.

Thanks,
David

LifeTrek on July 8, 2008 at 12:53 AM

Bush was accidentally correct. And that’s a hell of a lot better than being dead wrong.

Travis1 on July 8, 2008 at 10:33 AM

Comment pages:


You must be logged in to post a comment.