Hot Air Mobile
Home The Vault Gear About
Hot Air -- get your fill  

Spymania: Everything you think you know is might be wrong

posted at 10:14 pm on December 7, 2006 by Allahpundit
Send to a Friend | Share on Facebook | printer-friendly

Well, not quite everything. Just where, when, and how Litvinenko was poisoned.

First things first, though. Did he really convert to Islam? Sounds like it, but doubt lingers.

Earlier Thursday, Zakayev and Litvinenko’s father, Walter, joined hundreds of Muslims who had gathered at London’s Regent’s Park Mosque for regular daily prayer to attend a memorial service, where the imam recited a funeral prayer…

Walter Litvinenko and Zakayev both insisted the former spy had converted to Islam on his deathbed, although some friends disputed the claim — saying he had merely expressed empathy with Chechen Muslims. Siddiqui said the mosque had been told Litvinenko converted to Islam 10 days before he was admitted to a hospital last month.

Vladimir Bukovsky, a friend and fellow Putin critic, said Litvinenko had asked that his body eventually be moved to Chechnya.

The service at the burial site was nondenominational.

Now to the good stuff. The story all along has been that Litvinenko was dosed on November 1, probably during lunch at the sushi place with Scaramella. Wrong — on both counts, maybe.

As Alexander Litvinenko was buried yesterday investigators revealed that they now suspect that the former Kremlin spy was poisoned in the bar of a luxury London hotel when he met two Russian businessmen…

Michael Clark, of the agency’s radiation protection division, said last night that it was possible that Litvinenko was poisoned by a contaminated cigarette or drink.

A minute quantity of polonium-210 placed in Litvinenko’s glass would explain how he ingested the radioactive poison that led to his agonising death three weeks later.

The vapour that evaporated from the drink would have been inhaled by anyone in the area, with a greater concentration for his Russian companions and staff, who would have been in the bar much longer.

Investigators believe the poison cocktail was likely to have been manufactured in a guest room at the hotel, a short walk away from the US Embassy. Significant traces of polonium-210 were found in a fourth-floor room, which was occupied by a visiting Russian.

Police believe that the killer may have stalked Litvinenko in London that day and had first tried to poison the ex-KGB colonel in a sushi bar. That failed but the poisoner left ample traces of the deadly radioactive isotope in the Piccadilly restaurant.

This assumes, of course, that Litvinenko visited the sushi place before he went to the hotel bar — a point which, so far as I know, has never been settled. But let’s assume it’s true. How do we explain this, tucked away innocuously as an afterthought at the bottom of the same article?

Traces of polonium-210 has been found at Parkes Hotel, Mayfair, it was confirmed last night. It means that radiation has been found at all three hotels where Mr Lugovoy had stayed since flying to London on October 16. The Parkes was the first he stayed at.

The radioactive isotope has also been found at Risc Management, a security firm in Cavendish Place, visited by Litvinenko with Mr Lugovoy and Mr Kovtun on October 17.

There’s radiation at two sites that were patronized by Lugovoy before Litvinenko was poisoned? That’s … important, isn’t it? And rather incriminating?

What about the possibility that Litvinenko wasn’t poisoned on November 1 at all? Apparently it’s now being “explored”:

It is understood that detectives are also exploring whether Mr Litvinenko, 43, who died on 23 November, and Mr Kovtun were attacked before their 1 November meeting and may have been spreading contamination for a number of days.

Mr Kovtun is known to have spent three days in London from 16 October during which time he shared two meals with Mr Litvinenko, who had become a “fixer” for his trips to London. One of the meals was in the same Itsu sushi bar on Piccadilly where Mr Litvinenko ate on 1 November with another man, the Italian security expert Mario Scaramella.

Kovtun was the other man with Lugovoy at the meeting with Litvinenko in the hotel bar on November 1. There were reports today that he’s been hospitalized with radiation poisoning and is in critical condition, and possibly even comatose. The Independent claims that polonium’s been found in his digestive tract. Lugovoy’s lawyer denies that Kovtun is ill, as does a second unnamed source who spoke to CBS. Lugovoy is himself in the hospital right now; his condition is unknown.

And in the latest twist, seven workers at the hotel bar have tested positive for very small amounts of polonium. As you may recall, relatively high levels of polonium were also detected in the bar’s men’s room(?). It sounds like the poisoning must have happened there, probably on November 1, and that Lugovoy and/or Kovtun were involved either in smuggling the material into the UK in late October or they themselves are the assassins. If the meeting in the bar took place before the lunch date at the sushi place, it may be that the dose that hit Litvinenko was so huge that enough of it was left on his person to accidentally contaminate Scaramella with it later on.

Or is there yet another, darker possibility, as A.J. Strata has suggested? I’ll leave you with this, which comes from two guys who have been pushing the Adnan al-Shukrijumah threat for months now. The American Hiroshima is coming, they say, and Alexander Litvinenko might have played a small part in bringing it about. Crazy, yet compelling:

The neutron source or “triggers” of … suitcase nukes are composed of beryllium-9 and polonium-210. When these two elements are combined, the alpha particle is absorbed by the nucleus of the beryllium causing it to decay by emitting a neutron. Such “triggers” were a feature of early nuclear weapons in the U.S. and Soviet stockpiles.

Polonium-210 has a half-life of 138 days, necessitating the replacement of the triggers every six months. For this reason, the suitcase nukes are far from maintenance-free. In addition, the nuclear core of these devices emit a temperature in excess of one hundred degrees Fahrenheit - - further exposing the weapons to oxidation and rust. Small wonder that al Qaeda operatives including Adnan el-Shukrijumah, who are spearheading “the American Hiroshima” have received extensive training in nuclear technology.

Polonium-beryllium triggers are packaged in foil packs about the size of a package of sugar on a restaurant table. When the twin foil packages are crushed, the elements mix and the neutrons are emitted. A courier transporting nuclear triggers could have had a mishap causing the packages to rupture and a trail of contamination to occur.

Polonium-210 is a fine powder, easily aerosolized. Litvinenko could have inhaled the powder, or had a grain or two on his fingers when he ate the sushi.


Blowback

Note from Hot Air management: This section is for comments from Hot Air's community of registered readers. Please don't assume that Hot Air management agrees with or otherwise endorses any particular comment just because we let it stand. A reminder: Anyone who fails to comply with our terms of use may lose their posting privilege.

Trackbacks/Pings

Trackback URL

Comments

All right. I am at times, an visual learner, an audio learner, and a kinestetic learner. For this, I need a visual timeline to get it properly. Any suggestions?

CrimsonFisted on December 7, 2006 at 10:59 PM

Any suggestions?

Wait until there is a blogger with enough energy to make one. It probably won’t take long and it will likely come from some blogger on the fringes who desperately needs the link.

As for this whole Litvinenko nonsense, I’m not a conspiracy theorist, and I haven’t followed this thing as closely as some, but I must say my first reaction to his claim that ‘Putin got him’ was that it sounded really contrived, almost childish. Assume Litvinenko was smuggling this stuff to an el-Shukrijuma type - and screwed up, killing himself and apparently irradiating half of great britain - there is a ready made fall guy just aching to step up and take the blame. Blame it on Bu-err…I mean, blame it on Putin! Everyone would just lap that up, because not only does it fit preconceived notions, it’s sexy as hell. It’s what I’d do in that situation.

Of course, that doesn’t mean it’s not a bunch of conspiratorial rubish.

thelinyguy on December 7, 2006 at 11:07 PM

My head’s spinning on this topic.

NTWR on December 7, 2006 at 11:10 PM

Hoisting himself on his own nuclear petard sounds a lot more reasonable. The whole assassination thing never made much sense to me. Why kill somebody with something so obvious and traceable, when there are so many better ways of whacking somebody?

Not that this makes me feel any better. Oh well, at least I live in a town infested with jihadi-loving liberals. They won’t bother with us…

Hack Ptui on December 7, 2006 at 11:29 PM

Important to note: Polonium, being a heavy metal, does not dissolve readily in water…it sinks. It would have had to be either sprinkled on his food, or laced in a cigarette.

stonemeister on December 7, 2006 at 11:30 PM

If this murder mystery gets any more confusing, people are going to lose the plot and forget all about it, and the perpetrator’s not only going to get off scot free, but 7 years later, his wife will be elected Senator from a state she’s not from, then become a top contender for President.

flip on December 7, 2006 at 11:32 PM

He could have coincidentally been slightly ill from the sushi bar, then never came out of it, thus thinking he’d been socked at the restaurant when he’d been actually poisoned before that and hadn’t developed symptoms until after the sushi episode. Anyway, 72 hour rule needs to be stretched a lot longer for this strange business. No one even knows if the victim is lying or not, sooo odd this business has been.

naliaka on December 7, 2006 at 11:39 PM

RE: The Canadian Free Press article.
Also in World net daily: http://www.wnd.com/news/article.asp?ARTICLE_ID=46127

That is just too good. Who could make that up?

First rule in espionage - counter espionage:
NOTHING is what it first appears to be.

Best case scenario; itsa ’sittn round the camp fire telling
scary stories’ thing.

rockhauler on December 7, 2006 at 11:39 PM

“Wait until there is a blogger with enough energy to make one. It probably won’t take long and it will likely come from some blogger on the fringes who desperately needs the link.”

Usually I would fit that description, but I haven’t had more than 1 cup of coffee today, worked all day and have almost no energy left in me.

amerpundit on December 7, 2006 at 11:55 PM

Over a year ago on Front Page magazine:
http://www.frontpagemag.com/Articles/ReadArticle.asp?ID=18986
Itsa CFR plot. . .
Over a year ago on Al Jazeera: Good for a laugh. .
http://english.aljazeera.net/news/archive/archive?ArchiveId=16505
The World Net Daily story was posted Sept 3, 2005.

Google American Hiroshima returns 2.6 million hits.
Stir up the fire, and pass me the marshmallos wouldya?

Just why Russians are dying of radiation poisoning is another story.

rockhauler on December 8, 2006 at 12:07 AM

Important to note: Polonium, being a heavy metal, does not dissolve readily in water…it sinks.

Unless you convert it into a salt, and dissolve it in some type of solvent before you add it to the food or drink.

jic on December 8, 2006 at 12:38 AM

If indeed Kovtun is sick now that could mean he was poisoned after Litvinenko came in contact with the Polonium-210.

Finding contacts who Litvinenko and Kovtun have in common and also would be on the very short list of who has the availablity of Polonium-210 with the specific signature of this isotope on their person, I’m guessing is on the Scotland Yard Christmas wish list.

Could be interesting to find out.

Speakup on December 8, 2006 at 1:41 AM

I’m all about doubt, but I do get a bit puzzled when people posit an “American Hiroshima” scenario, then wonder how the Russians got involved.

Who has tons of nuclear material and experience, a history of dirty dealings, a need for money, and no great concern over the fate of the West?

Ding!

That’s not to say that’s what happened, but since we’re being all spooky and paranoid…

Merovign on December 8, 2006 at 2:57 AM

All I know is that you have more people poisoned or exposed to polonium. If I were a Brit and my government didn’t seriously hold the Russians feet to the fire, I would lose all confidence in my government.

EF on December 8, 2006 at 4:40 AM

If this is KGB (or whatever they’re called these days) it’s the sloppiest, most amateurish thing they’ve ever done. Is leaving such an obvious trail of evidence the way they go about things? Something’s very weird here.

Halley on December 8, 2006 at 5:20 AM

Important to note: Polonium, being a heavy metal, does not dissolve readily in water

It’s soluble in weak acids - Bloody Marys, Mimosas, Screwdrivers - another good reason not to drink before lunch.

RedWinged Blackbird on December 8, 2006 at 6:36 AM

It’s soluble in weak acids - Bloody Marys, Mimosas, Screwdrivers - another good reason not to drink before lunch.

RedWinged Blackbird on December 8, 2006 at 6:36 AM

Well, being a “racist pig”, wouldn’t he be drinking vodka?

E L Frederick (Sniper One) on December 8, 2006 at 8:08 AM

I believe that the “greatest story ever told” belongs to the story of the birth of Jesus Christ.

thoro on December 8, 2006 at 8:53 AM

Why kill somebody with something so obvious and traceable, when there are so many better ways of whacking somebody?

But Polonium is so much more exotic. And in itself a calling card. Dirty bombs, folks. They want us to know that all that nuclear material that had “disappeared” is now in some very powerful hands. The method was no accident—probably very well just a showcase of opportunity.

seejanemom on December 8, 2006 at 8:59 AM

Why kill somebody with something so obvious and traceable, when there are so many better ways of whacking somebody?

In today’s WaPo Krauthammer writes this:

Some say that the Litvinenko murder was so obvious, so bold, so messy — five airplanes contaminated, 30,000 people alerted, dozens of places in London radioactive — that it could not possibly have been the KGB.

But that’s the beauty of it. Do it obvious, do it brazen, and count on those too-clever-by-half Westerners to find that exonerating. As the president of the Central Anarchist Council (in G.K. Chesterton’s “The Man Who Was Thursday”) advised: “You want a safe disguise, do you? . . . A dress in which no one would ever look for a bomb? Why, then, dress up as an anarchist, you fool!”

The other reason for making it obvious and brazen is to send a message. This is a warning to all the future Litvinenkos of what awaits them if they continue to go after the Russian government. They’ll get you even in London, where there is the rule of law. And they’ll get you even if it makes negative headlines for a month.

Just some food for thought.

JaHerer22 on December 8, 2006 at 9:04 AM

Radioacive material smugglers+ islam = good riddance. Thank you, Mr Putin.

dhimwit on December 8, 2006 at 9:41 AM

…and the plot thickens. How strange.

CP on December 8, 2006 at 9:57 AM

Just some food for thought.

Ah, a plot so simple and obvious, yet so cunning in its layers upon layers of complexity–there’s only one person capable of such a plan: Karl Rove himself. I KNEW Bush was behind this!

Nah, but seriously, Krauthammer has a very good point, as usual. Either way, though, this assassination is not a good sign.

Hack Ptui on December 8, 2006 at 11:31 AM

Seems like Krauthammer’s got Putin in a darned if he does darned if he doesn’t situation.

If the ‘assassination’ were executed perfectly, everyone would say, “Only the Russian KGB (or Karl Rove) could pull of something that sinister.”

Because the ‘assassination’ was botched and there is evidence all over the place, he wants us to say, “It was obviously Putin telling the KGB to make it so messy that no one will think it was the KGB.”

I’d rather wait till at least some of the facts are in before I convict Putin.

Besides, Bush looked into his eyes. /sarcasm

JadeNYU on December 8, 2006 at 4:22 PM

I am most concerned about the use of polonium as a terrorist’s weapon, if indeed terrorists posess it in quantity. Suppose the next 9-11 was carried out by sleepers within a number of banks. At a prescribed time it is applied to currency in some form within these banks. The money circulates an no one is the wiser, even as the sleepers blow themselves up in an attempt to hide the fact that their bodies have the poison. How many people would be seriously injured or killed as the money circulates for several weeks before the tainting is discovered? How afraid would people be to accept currency thereafter?

I kinda hope it is Russia and not some other group in posession of this stuff. MAD was a deterrent with them. MAD would be the ends for a jihadist.

shuzilla on December 8, 2006 at 4:46 PM

In today’s WaPo Krauthammer writes this
The other reason for making it obvious and brazen is to send a message. This is a warning to all the future Litvinenkos of what awaits them if they continue to go after the Russian government. They’ll get you even in London, where there is the rule of law. And they’ll get you even if it makes negative headlines for a month.

While I have great respect for Charles Krauthammer, this is somewhat naive.
The intelligence community is made up of people who pick up on a subtle message very well.
Who then is a loud, bold message aimed at? Chechens or Syrians maybe? Unlikely.

If indeed Litvinenko converted to Islam on his deathbed, why? Why not some other religion?
Did he think Allah would forgive him better for his past deeds?
Perhaps he would be exonerated or exalted because he put so many enemies of Allah down like sick puppies?
Or maybe he just likes the idea of 72 virgins.

Speakup on December 8, 2006 at 7:51 PM


You must be logged in to post a comment.